Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

What can western management offer Russian social work?

By K. Gilbert


This paper contributes to the debate on the process and the efficacy of Western management 'knowledge' transfer by casting light on the ways in which it has had an impact on the largely neglected area of public service and public administration. The study from which the paper derives\ud took place in 1997 and 1998 in two social services departments in regions south of Moscow, and in the Ministry of Labour and Social Development (formerly Social Protection) in Moscow. The author is a British management academic acting as a consultant to the development of social work\ud management on a recent Tacis project. The paper is an ethnographic, participant observer account of working with Russian social workers, social work managers, and heads of service. In Russia, the institutions for protection of the most vulnerable groups in the population, and the\ud legislative frameworks for such institutions (the ‘social safety net’), are being radically re-drawn, in efforts to forestall the direst social consequences of a rapid shift to the market. Social work as a\ud profession is being shaped and defined within this context, and an infrastructure to manage and resource it is being gradually and painfully developed by its leaders, often in extremis. Social services\ud managers are struggling with a gargantuan task of reconciling the contradiction between vastly expanding public expectations and rapidly dwindling resources. Within this contradiction, Western influences, traditional Russian values and the harsh reality of the present, meet, collide and confront each other. Inherent tensions lead to the psychological phenomenon known as ‘splitting’ - the separating out of negative emotions or feelings judged unhelpful, and their projection onto other\ud groups. Using an ethnographic approach to a small number of recent consultancy episodes, the author contends that only those Western management approaches which can accommodate a diverse range of ideological positions will be helpful, because they will be recognised in terms of current\ud realities and comprehended as consistent with dominant values. No single set of values can yet be said to be dominant. The ensuing result is that a focus on developing practice in social work delivery is seen to be more relevant, and less problematical, than the transfer of new approaches to service management

Topics: Russia, Knowledge transfer, Western management techniques, Social work management, Public administration, Public service, Management practices
Publisher: University of Wolverhampton
Year: 1999
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1998). (Eds) The Old and the New: changes in social care in Central and Eastern Europe Kent:
  2. (1992). Behind the Factory Walls: decision-making in Soviet and US enterprises Boston MA: doi
  3. (1998). Consultancy Fatigue: epidemiology, symptoms and prevention doi
  4. (1997). Dealing with the
  5. (1997). Do Organizations Have Feelings? doi
  6. (1996). European Social Care Services: is it possible to identify models? doi
  7. (1995). Management Education in Russia: issues in course design, development and evaluation Manchester:
  8. (1992). On Becoming a Manager in Social Work London,
  9. (1992). Restructuring the Soviet doi
  10. (1993). Russian Management: how far from the West? doi
  11. (1960). Social Systems as a Defence Against Anxiety: an empirical study of the nursing service of a general hospital, In: E. Trist & H. Murray (Eds) doi
  12. (1992). Soviet Union, In: J. Dixon & D Macarov (Eds.) Social Welfare in Socialist Countries London: Routledge doi
  13. (1995). Success strategies for Russian-foreign joint ventures. doi
  14. (1994). The New Journey to Jerusalem: mission and meaning in the managerial crusade to doi
  15. (1998). The old and the New: changes in social care in Central and Eastern Europe Canterbury:
  16. (1999). What can Western Management Offer Russian Social Work? _________________________________________________________________________________________
  17. (1990). What we don't know about Soviet Management Harvard Business Review

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.