Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Managing diversity : the strategic planning of long term technology infrastructure

By Paul J. Jeffrey

Abstract

Current methods of addressing uncertainty in the field of technology planning and management rely heavily on the use of forecasting and scenario generation. However, current developments in the planning and systems literature suggest that concepts of diversity and resilience provide an alternative framework for addressing uncertainty. Consequently, this thesis adopts an interdisciplinary approach to investigate three specific aspects of the technology assessment process; the limits to information from quantitative modelling, technological and managerial strategies for combating uncertainty, and the roles of models and modellers in these strategies. As a preface to the study, the nature of resilience in the context of technology planning is reviewed and some propositions are made concerning the matching of planning tools with levels of management sovereignty. A series of simulation models developed as part of the research programme provide some useful insights into the role of diversity in promoting both reduced costs and greater cost stability over the long term. However, they also expose a number of methodological limitations to modelling diversity in technological systems. These limitations are associated with both the representation of diversity and the exposure of multiple solutions. The second strand of investigation shows that the flexibility promoted by managers active in a turbulent operating environment, is focused on organisational and human centred attributes of the firm's activities. The final research activity shows that professional modellers in the U. K. appear to be aware of the limitations of the tools and techniques they utilise and perceive their role as being one of providing a rational / scientific approach to problem solving. Both policy and methodology related conclusions are drawn from the three research activities. Integration of the various strands of the research results emphasises the importance of matching the strategic and decision issue contexts of a policy issue to the analysis and policy tools used. Several recommendations for further research are also provided

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 1992
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/4167
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1978). (Ed)'Adaptive Environmental Assessment and Management. '
  2. (1974). (Eds) 'Operations and Systems Analysis: A Simulation Approach' Allyn & Bacon.
  3. (1983). (Eds)' Handbook of Survey Research' doi
  4. (1963). A Behavioural Theory of the Firm. ' Prentice_Hall. Englewood Cliffs. doi
  5. (1970). A Concept of Corporate Planning: doi
  6. A Decision Analysis of the Effect of Uncertainty Upon Electric Utility Planning. doi
  7. (1965). A Factorial Experiment in Including Responses to a Mail Questionnaire. ' Sociology and Social Science Research.
  8. A Formal Decision Theoretic Approach to Flexibility and Robustness. ' doi
  9. A Generation Expansion Planning Model for Electric Utilities: The Engineering Economist. doi
  10. A Mathematical Model of the Adaptive Behaviour of Organisations. '
  11. A provisional classification of symbolic data.
  12. (1974). A Regionalized Electricity Model: Energy Laboratory Report No MITEL 75-005. Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
  13. A Sensitivity Assessment of Uncertainty in Infrastructure Expansion' doi
  14. (1978). A Systems View of Planning: Towards a Theory of the Urban and Regional Planning Process' doi
  15. (1975). Adaptation in Natural and Artificial Systems. ' doi
  16. Adaptation: A Promising Metaphor for Strategic Management' doi
  17. (1986). Adaptive Management of Renewable Resources' doi
  18. (1969). Alienation of Reason: A History of Positivist Thought' doi
  19. (1982). An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change. doi
  20. (1973). An Introduction to Confirmation Theory.
  21. Anonymity and Attitude Measurement' Public Opinion Quarterly. Vol doi
  22. Anonymity and Response by Salespeople to A Mail Questionnaire: doi
  23. (1963). Approaches to Dynamic Investment Programming. ' North-Holland.
  24. (1967). Arcadie, essais sur le mieux vivre. ' doi
  25. Assessing Risks Through the Determination of Rare Event Probabilities. ' doi
  26. (1989). at the Top'
  27. (1986). Basic Methods of Policy Analysis and Planning. ' Prentice-Hall. Englewood Cliffs. doi
  28. Benefits and Costs of Flexibility - Short Lead Time Power Plants: Long Range Planning. doi
  29. (1983). Beyond Prediction and Preparation' doi
  30. (1992). Biotechnics & Society: The Rise of Industrial Genetics. ' Praeger. doi
  31. Build Flexibility - Not Power Plants. ' Public Utilities Fortnightly.
  32. Can ergonomic uncertainty always be described by randomness ?'
  33. Capacity Expansion for Water Resources Facilities: A Control Theoretic Algorithm for Non-Stationary Theoretic Demands., Advances in Water Resources. doi
  34. Capacity Expansion of a Deteriorating Facility under Uncertainty.
  35. Capacity Expansion when Demand is a Birth-Death Random Process: doi
  36. (1986). Capital Investment and Financial Decisions' Prentice-Hall. Englewood Cliffs. doi
  37. Characteristics of Organizational Environments and Perceived Environmental Uncertainty. doi
  38. Choice of a Long Term Strategy for the National Electricity Supply Industry via Scenario Analysis and Multi Criteria Analysis. ' doi
  39. Choosing an Investment Programme Amongst Interdependent Projects: Review of Economic Studies. doi
  40. Clustering Countries on Attitudinal Dimensions: A Review and Synthesis' doi
  41. Cognitive Simplification Processes in Strategic Decision Making. ' doi
  42. Collective Strategy: The Social Ecology of Organisational Environments. '
  43. Commitment, Flexibility and Market Outcomes' doi
  44. (1982). Complexity and Cleavage: Dual Explanations of Strategic Decision Making' doi
  45. (1968). Computer Simulation Techniques' J. Wiley and Sons. doi
  46. Concentration and Specialization; Dynamics of Niche Width in Populations or Organizations: doi
  47. (1992). Concepts of Strategic Management. ' Harper Collins.
  48. (1952). Content Analysis in Communication Research' Free Press. doi
  49. Coping with Strategic Uncertainty. doi
  50. Corporate Point of View on Modelling. doi
  51. (1982). Cost Benefit Analysis. ' George Allen & Unwin. 3rd Edition.
  52. (1971). Cost Considerations in Systems Analysis' doi
  53. Critique of the Verification of Computer Simulation Models. doi
  54. (1980). Culture's Consequences' Sage. doi
  55. (1980). Decision Scientists, Decision Makers and the gap. doi
  56. Decision Support for Improving Systems Reliability by Redundancy. ' doi
  57. Decision Support Systems: An Empirical Assessment for Decision Making. ' Decision Sciences. doi
  58. Defending Against Uncertainty in the Electric Utility Industry. ' Energy Systems and Policy.
  59. Demand Fluctuations and Endogenous Firm Flexibility! doi
  60. (1977). Designing Complex Organizations: Addison_Wesley.
  61. (1984). Development Planning: An Adaptive Approach: Long Range Planning. Vol 17. No 5. doi
  62. Dimensions of Organisational Task Environments. doi
  63. Directiveness and Non-Directiveness in Research Interviewing: A Reformulation of the Problem' doi
  64. Diversification and Profitability Amongst British Manufacturing Companies 1972-1984' doi
  65. (1975). Diversity as a function of energy flow! in doi
  66. Does Response to an Offer of Mail Survey Results Interact with Questionnaire Interest ?'
  67. (1964). Economic Natural Selection and the Theory of the Firm. ' Yale Economic Essays. Vol 4.
  68. Effect of Anonymity on Return Rate and Response Bias in a Mail Survey: doi
  69. Effect of Participation in Strategic and Tactical Decisions on Acceptance of Planned Change. doi
  70. Effects of Anonymity and Social Setting on Survey Responses: Public Opinion Quarterly. Vol doi
  71. Electric Utility Capacity Expansion Planning With Uncertain Load Forecasts. ' doi
  72. Energy Strategy Planning for Electric Utilities: Part 1: SMARTE Methodology. ' doi
  73. (1958). Environment as an Influence on Managerial Autonomy. doi
  74. Environmental Uncertainty Reduction By Smoothing and Buffering: An Empirical Verification. ' doi
  75. (1990). Evaluation of Flexibility in Manufacturing Sysstems' doi
  76. (1992). Evolution, Sustainability and Industrial Metabolism. ' Paper prepared for publication in
  77. (1978). Evolutionary Ecology'. 2nd edition.
  78. Expectations and the Foundations of the Theory of Planning. ' doi
  79. (1984). Exploring Corporate Strategy. ' Prentice Hall. Englewood Cliffs. doi
  80. Facility Planning for a Public Services System: Domestic Solid Waste Collection. doi
  81. Fitness. ' doi
  82. Flexibility and Decision Making. ' doi
  83. Flexibility and the Theory of the Firm. '
  84. (1984). Flexibility and Uncertainty. ' doi
  85. Flexibility of Manufacturing Systems: Concepts and Measurements' doi
  86. (1973). Foundations of Behavioural Research' doi
  87. (1971). Frontiers of Quantitative Economics.
  88. Futures Research and Social Decision Making' Futures. doi
  89. (1968). General Systems Theory. '
  90. Generation Expansion Planning: An Expert Systems Approach' doi
  91. Global Sustainability: Towards Definition: Environmental Management. doi
  92. (1972). Guidelines for Project Evaluation' United Nations. doi
  93. (1976). How do we choose' doi
  94. (1968). Human Ecology: A Theory of Community Structure' doi
  95. Human Knowledge: The Role of Models, Metaphors and Analogy. ' doi
  96. (1972). Human Problem Solving'. Prentice HAIL. Englewood Cliffs. doi
  97. Human Resource Flexibility and Equity: Difficult Questions for Business, Labour and Government' doi
  98. Illusion or Reality? The Mathematics of Attainable Goals and Irreducible Uncertainties' doi
  99. In Search of Rationality: The Purposes Behind the Use Formal Analysis in Organizations. ' doi
  100. (1978). Incorporating Uncertainty in Energy Models: EPRI Research Project 1012-1.
  101. Individual Differences in Personality, Position in Organization and Job Satisfaction' doi
  102. Industry Variety and Performance. ' doi
  103. Information in Organizations as Signal and Symbol' Administrative Science Quarterly. doi
  104. Innovation, Diversity and Diffusion: A Self Organisation Model' doi
  105. (1987). Institutional Theories of Organization. ' doi
  106. Integrating Expert Systems with Dynamic Programming in Generation Expansion Planning' doi
  107. (1984). Interdisciplinary Research: Performance and Policy Issues. '
  108. Interpreting and Responding to Strategic Issues: The Impact of National Culture. doi
  109. Into the Swamp: The Analysis of Social Issues' doi
  110. Introducing Change to Transportation and Energy Systems: The Case of Alchohol Fuels. ' Transportation Planning and Technology. doi
  111. (1957). Introduction to Operations Research' doi
  112. (1982). Introduction to Political Economy. doi
  113. Investment Decisions Under Uncertainty: The "Irreversibility Effect":
  114. (1970). Investment Planning for the Electric Power Industry: An Integer Programming Approach'
  115. Irreducible Uncertainties: Society. doi
  116. Irreversibility, Uncertainty and Cyclical Investment. ' doi
  117. Issues in the Study of Professionalism in Organizations: The Case of Scientists and Engineers' Organizational Behaviour and Human Performance. doi
  118. Japanese Management: What About the Hard Skills ?' doi
  119. Least Cost Planning: A National Perspective: Public Utilities Fortnightly.
  120. Listening to Complexity: Analysing Qualitative Marketing Research Data. '
  121. (1969). Local Government and Strategic Choice: Tavistock Publications. doi
  122. (1978). Mail and Telephone Surveys: The Total Design Method. doi
  123. (1990). Management in the Land of Israel' Thomes.
  124. (1977). Management Policy and Strategy. doi
  125. Managerial Myopia: Self Serving Biases in Organizational Planning. ' doi
  126. Managerial Perceptions of the Future in a Volatile Society: The South African Case. doi
  127. (1984). Manufacturing Flexible Models and Measurements. '
  128. Manufacturing Strategy, Environmental Uncertainty and Performance. doi
  129. Matching Problem Diagnostic Tools to Manager's Decision Styles: A Cognitive Approach. doi
  130. Measurement of Adaptivity and Flexibility in Production Systems. ' doi
  131. Measurement of Diversity. doi
  132. (1984). Mingling Decision Making Metaphors: doi
  133. Minimum Cost Routing for Dynamic Network Models' Networks. Vol 10.1973. doi
  134. Modelling and Reality. ' doi
  135. (1992). Modelling to Predict or Learn T doi
  136. Models for Determining Least Cost Investments in Electricity Supply. ' doi
  137. Motivation Through the Design of Work: Test of a Theory. ' Organizational Behaviour and Human Performance. doi
  138. On a Formalisation of the Process of Quantitative Model Building. ' doi
  139. (1969). On Cartesian and Darwinian Aspects of Biology. '
  140. (1957). On Human Communication. ' doi
  141. On Measuring Economic Diverrsification: Land Economics. doi
  142. On Paradigmatic Progress in Public Policy and Administration' doi
  143. (1972). On Purposeful Systems. ' Intersystems Publications.
  144. On Some Aspects of Survival Under Production Uncertainty. ' Economic Theory. doi
  145. (1981). On Systems and Models. '
  146. (1974). On the Art of Modelling. '
  147. (1986). On The Effective Modelling doi
  148. On the Reality of Systems. ' Systems Practice. doi
  149. On the Use of Interactive Multi-Objective Linear Programming Methods for Long Term Energy Planning: Annals of Regional Scvience. doi
  150. One Dimensional Planning Theory. '
  151. (1978). Open Verses Closed Questions in Attitude Surveys. 'Paper Delivered at the Annual Meeting of the American Association for Public Opinion Research.
  152. Optimal Capacity Expansion Under Uncertainty. doi
  153. (1968). Optimal Capacity Policy with Irreversible Investment'
  154. (1982). Optimal Electric Utility Generation Expansion Under Uncertainty. ' doi
  155. (1974). Optimal Expansions of a Water Resources System. doi
  156. Optimal Investment Scheduling with Price Sensitive Dynamic Demand: doi
  157. Optimal Timing of Transmission Line Investments in the Face of Uncertain Demand. doi
  158. (1984). Order out of Chaos: Man's New Dialogue with Nature: Bantam Books. doi
  159. Organisational Structure and Strategiws of Control.. '
  160. (1967). Organization and Environment. ' doi
  161. Organizational Adaptation: Some Implications of Organizational Ecology for Strategic Choice. ' doi
  162. (1967). Organizations in Action. ' doi
  163. Participation Ideologies in Israeli Planning' doi
  164. Planning for Capacity Expansion: Stochastic Process and Game Theoretic Approaches. ' Socio-Economic Planning Sciences. doi
  165. Planning for New Electric Generation Technologies: A Stochastic Dynamic Programming Approach' doi
  166. Planning for Surprise: Water Resources Development Under Demand and Supply Uncertainty: 1. The General Model. ' doi
  167. (1987). Planning Under Pressure: The Strategic Choice Approach' Pergamon Press. doi
  168. Planning Under Uncertainty: The Inflexibility of Methodologies: doi
  169. Policies and Strategies: Four Fuzzy Concepts. ' doi
  170. (1992). Policy in a World of Evolution, Learning and Ignorance. ' Paper prepared for publication in
  171. Policy Making and Meaning as Design of Purposeful Systems. doi
  172. Policy Research and Analysis: An Empirical Profile 1975-1980. ' Policy Sciences. Vol doi
  173. (1950). Power and Democratic Planning' doi
  174. (1984). Practical Risk Analysis: An Approach Through Case Histories'
  175. Preference Modelling as a Reasoning Process: A New Way to Face Uncertainty in Multiple Criteria Decision Support Systems' doi
  176. (1928). Probability, statistics and truth' Hodge. doi
  177. (1939). Production and Distribution in the Short Run, ' doi
  178. Project Exit Value as a Measure of Flexibility and Risk Exposure: The Engineering Economist. doi
  179. (1981). Public Policy Analysis. ' Prentice-Hall. Englewood Cliffs. doi
  180. Qualitative Advertising Research' doi
  181. (1989). Rational Analysis for a Problematic World' doi
  182. (1970). Rationality. ' Basil Blackwell. doi
  183. Recent Publications on Research Survey Techniques. ' doi
  184. (1983). Renewing American Industry. doi
  185. (1973). Requiem for Large Scale Models. ' doi
  186. Resiliance and Stability of Ecological Systems. ' Annual Review of Ecological Systematics. doi
  187. (1974). Response Effects in Surveys: A Review and Synthesis: doi
  188. (1983). Risk Analysis and its Applications' doi
  189. (1990). Risk Analysis Using an Embedded CPA Package. doi
  190. Robustness & Optimality as Criteria for Strategic Decisions' doi
  191. Robustness in Sequential Investment Decisions. doi
  192. (1978). Science and Social Action' Alison and Busby.
  193. (1962). Scientific Method: Optimising Applied Research Decisions. doi
  194. Second Thoughts on the
  195. (1991). Self Modifying Systems in Biology and Cognitive Science: A New Framework for Dynamics, Information and Complexity. ' doi
  196. Sensitivity Analysis in Complex Decision Problems' doi
  197. Similarities Among Countries Based on Employee Work Values and Attitudes. '
  198. Simplifying the Complex: The Paradigms of Ecological Function and Structure. ' doi
  199. Simulating the Planning Advantages of Shorter Lead Time Generating Technologies'
  200. (1982). Simulation Modelling and Analysis: doi
  201. Solving an Electricity Generation Capacity Expansion Problem by Generalized Bender's Decomposition: doi
  202. South Wales: A Case Study in Industrial Diversification: Economic Geography. doi
  203. Strategic Choice of Flexible Production Technologies and Welfare Imnplications: doi
  204. (1979). Strategic Planning: What Every Manager Must Know: doi
  205. (1980). Strategies for Change: Logical Incrementalism' Erwin-Dorcey.
  206. Strategy Formulation: The Impact of National Culture. doi
  207. (1975). Systems Simulation: The Art and Science. ' Prentice-Hall. Engelwood Cliffs. doi
  208. (1986). Technological Competition, Uncertainty and Oligopoly. ' Discussion Paper #196. Centre for the Study of Organizational Innovation.
  209. (1967). Technological Forecasting in Perspective: OECD. doi
  210. Technological Infrastructure and the Implementation of Technological Strategies. doi
  211. The "Investment 85" Model of Electricite de France. ' Management Science. Vol 17.1970. doi
  212. (1971). The Age of Discontinuity. doi
  213. The Architecture of Complexity. ' doi
  214. (1951). The Art of Asking Questions. doi
  215. The Credibility of Policy Analysis: Between Method and Use: doi
  216. (1977). The Curious Behaviour of Complex Systems: Lessons from Ecology. '
  217. The Dominant Logic: A New Linkage Between Diversity and Performance. doi
  218. The Dynamics of Primary Energy Substitution. ' doi
  219. The Effect of Decision Making Styles and Contextual Experience on Executives Descriptions of Organizational Problem Formulation. ' doi
  220. The Effect of Demand Uncertainty on the Relative Economics of Electrical Generation Technologies with Differing Lead Times'
  221. The Effect of Sequence of Outcomes in a Chance Task on the Illusion of Control. ' doi
  222. The Effects of Uncertainty on Investment Under Risk Neutrality with Endogenous Information; doi
  223. The Evolution of Management Science Practices in Israel' doi
  224. The Flexibility Debate: Industrial Relations and New Management Production Practices' Labour and Industry. doi
  225. The Functions of Technology Infrastructure in a Competitive Economy. doi
  226. (1982). The Fundamental Principles of Flexibility in Manufacturing Systems:
  227. (1970). The Illusion of Control:
  228. The Impact of Changing Environments and Political Orientation Upon Price Fluctuations in Israel'
  229. The Influence of Economic Diversity on Unemployment and Stability. '
  230. The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields. doi
  231. (1972). The Limits of Growth.: A Report for the Club of Rome: Universal Books. doi
  232. (1961). The management of Innovation. doi
  233. The Myth of Turbulence: Futures. doi
  234. (1988). The Nature of Expertise. ' Erlbaum.
  235. The Nature of Policy Studies: A Content Analysis doi
  236. (1960). The New Science of Mangement Decisions.
  237. (1986). The Qualitative Story'.
  238. (1986). The Role of Mathematics in Modelling, Particularly Under Uncertainty. ' Paper Presented at
  239. The Role of Models in Science'
  240. The Role of Operational Research in Organizational Decision Making: doi
  241. (1959). The Science of Muddling Through: Public Administration Review. doi
  242. (1976). The Social Animal. ' Freeman.
  243. The Specialist with a Universal Mind:
  244. (1985). The symbolic uses of politics. ' doi
  245. The Theory of Choice Under Subjective Risk and Uncertainty. doi
  246. (1986). The Typology of Surprises in Technology, Institutions and Development. in 'Sustainable Development of the Biosphere. '
  247. The Use of Operational Research in Twelve Companies Quoted on the Stockholm Stock Exchange. ' doi
  248. The Value of Waiting to Invest. ' doi
  249. Theory of Fitness in a Heterogenous Environment. 1: The Fitness Set and Adaptive Function. ' doi
  250. (1981). Theory'Z'!
  251. Thesis of a new Reformation: The Social Fallout of Science 300 Years After Newton' Public Administration Review. doi
  252. Three Types of Perceived Uncertainty About the Environment: State, Effect, and Response Uncertainty. ' doi
  253. (1989). Thriving on Chaos: Handbook for a Management Revolution' 2nd Edition.
  254. Time to Build, Option Values and Investment Decisions. ' doi
  255. Towards an Ecological Economics. of Sustainability. ' doi
  256. Transferability of Japanese Human Resource Management Abroad. ' Human Resource Management. doi
  257. Uncertainty and Risk Analysis' Long Range Planning. doi
  258. Uncertainty, Evolution and Economic Theory. ' doi
  259. Use of intervals and possibility distributions in economics analysis:
  260. (1984). Variety in Strategic Planning: An Alternative to the Problem Solving Approach'
  261. Why Risk Analysis isnt Working. ' Long Range Planning. doi
  262. (1990). Why The Future is Not What it Was. ' Futures July/August. doi
  263. World Models, Their Progress and Applicability. doi
  264. (1983). Zero Inventories' Dow Jones-Irwin. Homewood Illinois.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.