Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

'BROTHERS IN ARMS'?: The American and British Coalition on the Western Front, 1918

By M Yockelson


This dissertation examines in detail, the organisation, training and operations of the 27 th and 30th American Divisions during the period of Summer 1917 to the announcement of an armistice in November 1918. Particular emphasis is placed on the two divisions after they were attached to the 11 American Corps. especiallý their experience with the British Expeditionary Force in 1918, and the training received under the supervision of British officers. The 11 American Corps was unique in that it spent its entire service in France in the British sector. Originally it was composed of 10 divisions, but eight of these were removed by the commander of the American Expeditionary Forces, Gen. John. J. Pershing. The divisions were transferred to the First American Army and operated entirely independent of 11 American Corps. The týýo American divisions that h, oth remained with the British, the 27t and -3 , relied heavily upon their coalition partners for advice in training, supplies, equipment, food and more importantly, tactical leadership. Although General Pershing forbade American divisions from being th -, oth amalgamated into Allied armies, in reality, the 27 and -) Divisions became part of the BEF, especially the Fourth Arrný during the final campaigns of the war. Despite its attachment to arguably the best fighting force on the Western Front in 1918, the 11 American Corps suffered heavý casualties during its limited operational experience and. in many ways. failed to take advantage of lessons learned by the British Army during its campaigns of 1916-1917. This dissertation concludes that the relationship between the two American divisions and their British ally was in the end result a success. By allowing the 27 th and 30'hDivisions to remain behind with the BEF, Pershing provided the British with more than 50,000 able American troops to use at the front. Thus the tNNo ,a llies became Brothers-in-Arms

Topics: World War I, Western Front, World War, 1939-1945 - Campaigns - Western Front, Soldiers - US and UK - Biography
Publisher: Department of Management and Security Analysis
Year: 2009
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (1999). 0., After the Trenches: The Transformation of U. doi
  2. (1985). 145 On the Western Front: Soldiers' Stories ftom France and Flander-s 1914-1918 (Phoenix Mill: Budding Books,
  3. (1944). 2 7"ý Division Summaty of Operations in the World War
  4. (1964). 336 Baynes, John, Far From a Donkey The Life ofSir Ivor Maxse (London: Brassey's.
  5. (1918). 354 'The Evolution of British Strategy and Tactics on the Western Front. doi
  6. (1918). 4 Short Histon, Qf the 105'h Infantry, United StatesArmy (Philadelphia:
  7. (1985). A Biography (Melbourne: doi
  8. (1924). A Committee of Officers who served with the Battalion, The War History Qf the Sixth Battalion, The South Staffordshire Regiment (TF),
  9. (1934). A Critical Anaývsis of the Operations of ihe American H Corps, from September 20 to October 2,1918. " The Command and General Staff School. Fort
  10. (2001). A ei t: York'S Silk Stocking Regiment and the Breaking of the Hindenburg Line (Washington: Brassey*s Inc.. doi
  11. (1992). A Few 'Squads-Left'and off to France: Training the. American Army in the United Statesfor World War I"
  12. (2003). A Fraternity ofArms. - America and France in the Great War (Lawrence:
  13. (1934). A Frenchman in Khaki (London:
  14. (2001). A History of the British at War (London: Little, Brown, and Company,
  15. (1918). A SurveY of German Tactics (Historical Section, AEF General Staff. The Base Printing Plant,
  16. (1978). A War: 1918, The Year of Victory (London: Sidgewick and Jackson Limited,
  17. (2000). A Youth in the Meuse-Argonne. - A Memoir, 191 --1918. edited ý\ ith an introduction by Robert H. Ferrell (Columbia: doi
  18. (1985). Acts of War. - The Behavior of Men in
  19. (1914). Ae Evolution of Victory: British Battles on the lVestern Front,
  20. (2003). Aerial Tactics of the Aces of World War I (London: Greenhill Books,
  21. (1917). Amalgamation: A Critical Issue in British-American Command Relations,
  22. (1983). Ambivalent Warfare: The Tactical Doctrine of the AEF in World War I-" Parameters
  23. (1918). American Expeditionary Forces,
  24. (1998). Amiens to the Armistice:
  25. (1999). An Intimate History of Killing: Face-to-Face Killing in 20, h Century Warfare (Basic Books, doi
  26. (1988). An Ocean Apart: The Relationship Betiveen doi
  27. (1994). and Trenches: First Hand A cco unts of Tank It arfare in the First World War (Sutton Publishers,
  28. (1918). Arm\ War College: GPO,
  29. (1998). Army Counterinsurgency and Contingency Operations Doctrine, doi
  30. (1920). Army in the World War, 19 Volumes,
  31. (1997). Army of the British Empire. - The Canadian Corps doi
  32. (1914). Army The Raising of., New Armies, doi
  33. (1982). ArmY Weapons and Theories at War, 1904-1945 (London: George Allen and Unwin,
  34. Between the Big Parades
  35. (1914). Bi 11, Surviving Trench Warfare: Technolokný and the Canadian Corps,
  36. (1969). Blood on the Border: The United States ArmY and the Mexican Irregulars (Toronto: doi
  37. (1995). Bloody April ... Black September: An r, Exciting and Detailed Analysis of the Two Deadliest Months in the Air in World I Var One (London: Grub Street Press,
  38. (1919). Books, Dissertations, and Theses A Company, History of the 301" Tank Battalion (Philadelphia:
  39. (1919). Breaking the Hindenburg Line: The Story of the 46 th (North Midland) Division (London: T. Fisher Unwin,
  40. (1918). British Expeditionary Force Campaign Orchestration and Fourth Army Operational Executions at the Battle of the Selle River,
  41. (1914). British Generalship on the Western Front, doi
  42. (1914). British Intelligence and the German Army, doi
  43. (1996). British Tommy (Oxford:
  44. (1923). BrumNý ell. History of the I-"h (Eastern) Division in the Great War (London: Nisbet &
  45. (1914). Cameos of the Western Front, Ypres Sector,
  46. (1920). Canada in the Great World War: An.
  47. (1980). Canadian Airmen and the First World 11'ar. - The / Royal Canadian Air Force, Volume I (Toronto: Universitý of Toronto Press, doi
  48. (1917). Chemical Warfare in World War L TheAmerican Experience,
  49. (1993). Coalitions, Politicians & Generals. -Some Aspects of Command in Two World J, doi
  50. (2002). Command and Cohesion: The Citizen Soldier and Minor Tactics doi
  51. (1914). Command on the Western Front: The Militurv Career of Sir Henry Rawlinson,
  52. (1919). Companies (London: Waterlow Brothers &
  53. (1919). compiler, The Pictorial Record of the 27 th Division (New York: Harper and Brothers,
  54. (1918). Defining Victory (Canberra: Army Historý Unit, Department of Defence,
  55. (2000). Diggers Fourth of July. " (Militan,
  56. Division: The Stot-v Qf Its Sacrifices and. 4chievements (1919). Eý,, Oers. John H., The 27th 140 Ellis,
  57. (1963). Douglas Haig: The Educated Soldier
  58. (1918). during World War I (Neýý York: American Legion.
  59. (1996). editors, Facing Armageddon: The First Iforld War Experienced doi
  60. (1914). Editors, Staff Officer: The Diaries of Lord Moynes,
  61. (1931). Experiences in the Great War. doi
  62. (1976). Eye Deep in Hell: Trench Warfare in World War I (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins
  63. (1996). Fighting Methods in the Great War (London: Frank Cass,
  64. (1918). Fighting Soldier: The. AEF in doi
  65. (1984). For the Common Defense: A Military Histoij, of the United States doi
  66. (2003). Forgotten Voices of the Great War: A New History of WWI in the words of the Men and Women who were there (London:
  67. (1914). Fortifications of the Western Front,
  68. (1927). Fothergil 1. The Histoly of the 216'h Lancashire Fusiliers (Rochdale: The 'Observer' General Printing Works,
  69. (2003). France and the Great War, 1914-1918 (Cambridge: doi
  70. Francis, 11, Experiences in the Great War (North Carolina:
  71. (1918). Friendship: Anglo-American Relations, doi
  72. (1977). General of the Armies (Bloomington: University of Indiana "Venereal Disease: The AEF's Experience.
  73. (1997). Geography: Terrain Evaluation and the British Western Front, 1914-1918, " doi
  74. (1914). Geoloýý of the Western Front,
  75. (1983). George and the Generals (Newark: doi
  76. (1976). Haig (London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson,
  77. (1999). Haig: A Reappraisal '0 Years On (South Yorkshire: Leo Cooper and Pen &
  78. (1914). Histories of Two Hundred and Fýfo-one Divisions (ýOhe German Army, which participated in the Great War,
  79. (1920). History of 1191h Infia nt ry,
  80. (1983). History of the Militia and the National Guard (New York: MacMi I Ian,
  81. (1969). History of the South Stqffordshire Regiment (Aldershot: Gale &
  82. (1920). History qf the 10 7hInfantty US.
  83. (1918). History qf the 108 ih It? /antry,
  84. (1919). Histoty of the 27 Ih .-New York's Own (New York: Bennett and Churchill,
  85. (1918). Hole to Chateau with Company I. - Personal Recollections of a Line Officer of the 10 7hU S. Infantry Regiment,
  86. (2000). How The War Was If "on. -
  87. IAm the Guard: A History of the Army National Guard, doi
  88. (2004). Iflicii the Soldiers Came to Town: Spartanburg's Camp Wadsworth (1917-19) & Camp Crqft (1941-45) (Spartanburg: Spartanburg County Historical Association,
  89. (1998). Imperial War Museum Book of 1918. - Year of Victory (London:
  90. (1929). It Might Have Been Lost
  91. (1988). L The First World War
  92. (2000). Leadership in the Trenches: Officer-Man Relations, Morale and Discipline in the British A rmýi - in the Era of the First World War (London: Mac MiII an.
  93. (1997). Learning Lessons in the American Expeditionary Forces (Washington,
  94. (1920). Letters of a Soldier
  95. (1914). Lupfer, Timothy T., The Dynamics of Doctrine: The Changes in German Tactical Doctrine During the First World War (Fort Leavenworth, KS: Command and General Staff College,
  96. (2003). Mad Harry: Australia's Most Decorated Soldier (East Roseville:
  97. (1978). Make the Kaiser Dance
  98. (1957). Manuscript Collections Australian War Memorial, Canberra AWM 26-Operational War Diaries AWM30-Private Papers Collection A WM 44-Official History Manuscript AWM 51 -Security Classified Records 3DRL 3376-Field Marshal Sir William Birdwood Papers
  99. Marix, American Voices of World War I. - Primary Source Documents, 1917-1920 (Chicago: Fitzroy Dearborn, doi
  100. (1998). Memories of World War I. - North Carolina Doughboys on the Western Front (Raleigh: North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources,
  101. (2003). Military College of Science. doi
  102. (1985). Monash as Military Commander (Melbourne:
  103. (1938). Monuments Commission, American Battlefields doi
  104. (1997). Morale in the American Expeditionary Forces during World War
  105. (1918). My Personal Experience in the World War" (Papers of
  106. (2002). News From the Front: War Correspondents on the Western Front,
  107. (1980). No Man's Land 1918, The Last Year of the Great War (New York: Konecky & Konecky, doi
  108. (1925). of the Un ited States .4 rm,
  109. Official History of the 120 th Infantry "3 rd North Carolina "
  110. (1943). Official History of the Australian Army MedicalServices (Canberra: Australian War Memorial,
  111. (1962). Official History of the Canadian Army in the First World TVar. - Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914-1919 (Ottawa: Queen's Printer and Controller of Stationery.
  112. (1918). Operations: Belgium and France, doi
  113. (1992). Order of Battle of Divisions, Part 5A, The Divisions ofAustralia, Canada andNew Zealandand Those ofEastAfrica (Ray Westlake-Military Books,
  114. (1948). Order of Battle of the United Land Forces in the Iforld War,
  115. (1914). Order of Battle, Part 4, The Army Council,
  116. (1914). Organisation, Structure, Orders of Battle, translated by C. F. Colton (Solihull: Helion
  117. (1966). Over There with O'Ryan's Roughnecks (Seattle:
  118. (1994). Paddy, Battle Tactics on the Western Front: The British Arm. v'S Art qfAttack. 1916-1918,
  119. (1917). Pershing and Relief for Cause in the American Expeditionary Forces,
  120. (1925). Personalities and Reminiscences of the War
  121. (2001). Pessimism and British War Polic : 1916-1918 (London: Frank Cass. y doi
  122. Pillars of Fire: The Battle of Messines Ridge, doi
  123. (1968). President Wilson Fights His War: World War IAnd The American Intervention (Macmillan Company, doi
  124. (2000). Private Wars: Personal Records of the ANZ4CS in the Great War ( Victoria:
  125. (1989). Quartermaster Support of the Army: doi
  126. (2002). Race to the Front: The Materiel Foundation Qf Coalition Strategn,
  127. (1921). Records of the World War: Field Orders, 2 nd Army Corps
  128. (1969). Relations, 1917-1918: The Role of Sir William Wiseman (Princeton: doi
  129. (1923). Robert Bacon: Life and Letters doi
  130. (2000). Seeking Victory on the Western Front. - The British Army and Chemical Warfare in World War I (Lincoln: doi
  131. (1998). Sir William Robertson: Chief of the Imperial General Staff in the Great War (Westport: Praeger, doi
  132. (1919). Somine Qf Wallach. Jehuda L.. UNEASYCOALITION: The Entente Experience in World War I (Westport:
  133. (1914). Stormtroop Tactics: Innovation in the German ArmY, doi
  134. (1917). Tactical Dysfunction in the AEF. doi
  135. (1994). Tactics, Technology, and the Searchfor Victotý, on the Western Front in World War I (Novato:
  136. (1922). The 18 th Division in the Great War (Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons,
  137. (1973). The AEF and Coalition War Making. doi
  138. (2003). The AEF Way of War: doi
  139. (1917). The American Army in France,
  140. (2005). The American Expeditionary Forces in World War I (Oxford: Osprey Books,
  141. (1927). The American Reinforcement in the World War (Garden City: Doubleday,
  142. (2004). The ANZ4C Experience. - New Zealand, Australia and Empire the First World War (New Zealand: Reed,
  143. (1993). The ANZ4C Illusion (Cambridge:
  144. (1918). The Austral ian-American Tank Action at Hamel,
  145. (1984). The Australian Fl ing Corps in the Western and Eastern Theatres o War, y ýf 1914-1918
  146. (1918). The Australian Victories in France in
  147. (1999). The Battle of Hamel: The Australians' Finest Victoty (Kangaroo Press,
  148. (1972). The Battle of the Books, "
  149. (1918). The Battlefor Europe,
  150. (1917). The Birth ofAmerican Armor,
  151. (1914). The British Army. French Farmers and the War on the Western Front, doi
  152. (1918). The British Campaign in France and Flanders: July to
  153. (2004). The British Soldier in the First World War (London: Harper Collins,
  154. (1952). The Broadus Bailey Papers The Timberman-Fiske Family Papers 11 American Corps Soldiers Questionnaires 27 th
  155. (1989). The Defeat of Imperial Germany. - 1917-1918 (C h ape IHi 11: AI go nquin Press,
  156. (1963). The Doughboys
  157. (1951). The Evolution of the Supreme War Council: The Unified Command and the First American ArmY
  158. The First World War (3). - The Western Front, doi
  159. (2001). The First World War Myths and Realties (London:
  160. (1997). The First World War: Germany and A ustria-Hungaty,
  161. (1918). The German Offensives of doi
  162. (1986). The Great War and the British People doi
  163. (1985). The Great War and the French People doi
  164. (1918). The Great War Generals on the Western Front,
  165. (1914). The Great War, doi
  166. (1990). The Great War, 1914-1918: Essays on the Militan-, Political, andSocial History of the First World War (College Station: Texas
  167. The Great War, 1914-45: VolumeZ Who Won? Who Lost? (London: Harper Collins Publishers,
  168. (1999). The Great War. - doi
  169. (1997). The Hindenburg Line (London: Leo Cooper,
  170. (1919). The History of the 102 nd Mp. (Kai Schwensen.
  171. (1920). The History of the A.
  172. (2003). The Illusion of Victory: America in World War I (New York: Basic Books, doi
  173. (1939). The Infantry Journal, Infantry in doi
  174. (1998). The Inspector General of the United States .4 rin-i -.
  175. (2003). The Kaiser's War. '
  176. (1918). The Last Act
  177. (1997). The Last Days of Innocence (New York: Random House,
  178. (2004). The Learning Curve: The 46hNorth Midland Division on the Western Front.
  179. (1977). The Life and Times ofJohn
  180. (1920). The Literary Digest History of the World War, doi
  181. (1914). The Long Silence: Civilian Life Under the German Occupation of northern France, doi
  182. the Officer Corps of the United States. doi
  183. (2002). The Progress ofA Monstrous War Machine doi
  184. (1919). The QuarterlyArmy Listfor the Quarter Ending 30'h
  185. (1983). The Questionable Training of the AEF in World War I. - Parameters (XXII,
  186. (1962). The Sanguine Years, doi
  187. (1992). The Smoke and the Fire: Myths & doi
  188. The Story of the Fourth Army in the Battles of The Hundred Days,
  189. (1916). The Strategy of the Lloyd George Coalition, doi
  190. (2005). The Sweetheart of the A.
  191. (1987). The Test of Battle: The American Expeditionao, Forces in the MeuseArgonne Campaign (Newark:
  192. (1936). The Thirtieth Division in the World War (Lepanto, Arkansas: Old Hickory Publishing Company.
  193. (1918). The Unexpected Victory (London: Arms and
  194. (1918). The United States Infanti-j,. - An Illustrated Histotý,,
  195. (2002). The Unquiet Western Front: Britain's Role in Literature and History (Cambridge: doi
  196. (1996). The UntoldStoi-v (Ne\\ Haven:
  197. (2003). The Victorians at War (London: Hambledon and London, doi
  198. (1937). The War in the A ir. - Being the Story of the Part Played in Great War by the Royal Air Force, Volume VI. doi
  199. (1937). The War in the Air,
  200. (1937). The War in the Air: Appendices (Clarendon Press.
  201. (1914). The War the Infantry Knew,
  202. (1968). The War To EndAll Wars: The American Militutý, Experience in World War I (New York:
  203. (1940). These jVen. - For Conspicuous Braveiý, above and Beyond the Call of Duty (Harrisburg: Military Service Publishing Company.
  204. (1938). Through the Fog of War (London.
  205. (1918). Through the Hindenburg Line: Crowning Days on the Western Front (London: Hodder and Stoughton,
  206. (1936). to Armistice and Reflections (London:
  207. (1918). To the Last Man. - Spring
  208. (2004). Trench Knives and Mustard Gas. - With the 42 nd Rainbow Division in France, edited with and introduction by Robert H. Ferrell (College Station: Texas
  209. (1980). Trench Warfare, 1914-1918: The Live and Let Live System (London: doi
  210. (1998). Until the Last Trumpet Sounds: The Life of General of theArmies doi
  211. (1918). War and Peace (Woodstock, Nm York: The Ox erlook Press.
  212. (1917). We Just Got Here: The American Expeditionaty Force in France,
  213. (2001). Who'S Who in World War One doi
  214. (1918). With Guts and Ba onets. - Diggers and Doughboys on the Hindenburg Lille, y
  215. World War I Manuscript Collection East Tennessee History Museum, Knoxville, Tennessee Lawrence D. Tyson Papers Houghton Library, Harvard University, Cambridge BMS AM 1323 Imperial War Museum, Department of Documents.
  216. (2002). World War I Mobilization Camps. " The Journal of. 4merica's Military Past (Volume XXVIX, Fall/Winter
  217. (1918). World War One: Tank Battle at Hamel.
  218. (1922). ýeventy-First New York in the World War (N eý\ York: Robe rt SSutliffe,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.