Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

A study of leadership styles of female and male managers in 10 different nationality banks in Luxembourg, using the Personal Attributes Questionnaire and personal interviews

By Isabelle Cames

Abstract

This thesis is concerned with the similarities and Merences between the leadership styles of female and male' managers in general, 'and their respective levels of Instrumentality and Expressiveness in particular. In view of the lack of research, involving managers of both sexes in real work settings and in non Anlgo-Saxon environments, the present research has been conducted in the multi-cultural environment of the Luxembourg banking sector, with female and male managers from 13 different countries. A total of 33 female and 33 male managers, working in 10 banks of different nationalities, completed the Personal Attributes Questionnaire (PAQ) and were interviewed. The objectives of the research were to measure and compare the perceived levels of Instrumental and Expressive traits, as well as to analyse the perceived leadership styles of the participating managers themselves, their superiors and successful managers in their respective banks. Individual case studies were used to clarify and compare the feminine, masculine and androgynous leadership styles of participating managers from the 3 main PAQ categories, in order to establish whether the *managers' descriptions of themselves are in line with their PAQ results. Finally, 3 banks were chosen to represent the highest, the median and the lowest scores of the banks' nationalities on Hofstede's Masculinity Index, in order to establish whether differences on leadership styles exist between the banks in accordance with Hofstede's research. The present thesis has shown female managers, to possess exceptionally high levels of Instrumental traits compared to the male managers of this study, as well to women and men from other studies. In addition, the leadership styles measured by the PAQ categories to which the participating managers belong, were found to be consistent with the leadership styles they attribute to themselves. Significant differences were established between the 3 different nationality banks, but not in accordance with Hofstede's findings

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 1997
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/3863
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (1980). A Comparison among five Masculinity-Fen-dninityAndrogyny Instruments and two Mediods of Scoring Androgyny'. Australian PZLc; doi
  2. (1979). A Comparison of the Adjective Check List, doi
  3. (1997). A Comparison of the Career Paths Used by Successful Women and Men'.
  4. (1987). A Consumees Guide to Dual-Career Marriages'.
  5. (1987). A Cultural View of Organizational Change. Working Paper 10: INSEAD,
  6. (1972). A Model of Coping with Role Conflict: the Role Behaviour of College Educated Women'. Administrative Science Quarterly, doi
  7. (1990). A New Age for Business?.
  8. (1981). A Psychometric Analysis of the Personal Attributes Questionnaire'. doi
  9. (1964). An Introduction to Motivation.
  10. (1987). and The Center for Creative Leadership
  11. (1990). Androgyny and Leadership Style'. doi
  12. (1993). Approaches to Social Enquiry. doi
  13. (1990). Are Women Different and Why are Women Thought to Be Different? Theoretical and Methodological Perspectives'. doi
  14. (1990). At the Heart of Women in Management Research: Theoretical and Methodological Approaches and Their Biases'. doi
  15. (1996). Banking in Luxembourg: Facts and Figures.
  16. (1979). Bem, Sex Role Inventory. A lbeoretical and Methodological Critique'. doi
  17. (1989). Career Couples. Unwin Hyman,
  18. (1984). Career Mobility in a Corporate Hierarchy. doi
  19. (1997). Central de la Statistique et des Etudes Economiques doi
  20. (1981). Comments on Median Split Procedures for Scoring Androgyny Measures'. Sex Roles, doi
  21. (1981). Comparacion Transcultural y Analysis Psicometrico de una Medida de Rasgos Masculinos (Instrumentales) y Femininos (Expresivos)'. Revista de la Associacion Latinamericana de Psicologia Social,
  22. (1984). Concurrent Validity of Four Androgyny Instruments. Sex Roles, 11,813-837. 245 246 APPENDICES 247 z. w 129 4) Qg loQI e, --Z ce .
  23. (1986). Coping with Powerlessness: The Relationship of Gender and Job Dependency to Empowerment Strategy Usage. doi
  24. (1992). Cracking the Glass Ceiling: Overcoming Isolation and Alienation'.
  25. (1993). Cracks in the Glass: The Silent Competence of Women'. Business Horizons March - doi
  26. (1992). Cross-Currents in the River of Time: Conceptualizing the Complexities of Women's Careers'. doi
  27. (1984). Cultural Variafions in Sex-Typing'. doi
  28. (1984). Culture's Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values -Abridged Edition. doi
  29. (1991). Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind. doi
  30. (1988). Deceptive Distinctions: Sex, Gender, and the Social Order. doi
  31. (1976). Defacto Discrimination and How to Kick the Habit'.
  32. (1994). Designing Funded Qualitative Research'.
  33. (1972). Determinants of Coalitional, Behaviour of Men and Women: Sex Roles or Situational Requirements? '. doi
  34. (1991). Differentiated Additive Androgyny Model: Relations Between Masculinity, Femininity, and Multiple Dimensions of Self-Concept'. doi
  35. (1988). Dimensionality of the Personal Attributes Questionnaire: An Empirical Replication'.
  36. (1984). Dimensions of Need for Power: Personalized vs. Socialize Power in Female and Male Managers'. doi
  37. (1991). Do the BSRI and PAQ Measure the Same or Different ConceptsT. doi
  38. (1974). Effect of Applicant Sex and Difficulty of Job Evaluations of Candidates for Managerial Positions'. doi
  39. (1985). Emergence and Characterization of Sex Differences in Spatial Ability: A Meta-Analysis'. Child Develgpment, doi
  40. (1995). EV., The Essence of Women
  41. (1979). Facilitating the Entry of Women into Management Posts'.
  42. (1980). Female Managers and Quahty of Working Life: The Impact of Sex-Role Stereotypes'.
  43. (1985). Feminine Leadership or How to Succeed in Business Without Being One of the Boys. Time Books,
  44. (1990). Frontiers and New Vistas in Women in Management Research'. doi
  45. (1986). Gender and Helping Behavior: A Meta-Analytic Review of the Social Psychological Literature'. doi
  46. (1990). Gender and Leadership Style: A Meta-Analysis'. doi
  47. (1985). Gender and Social Psychology, (Eds) OEeary VE. et aL:. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. 'Gender and Influenceability. Stereotype versus Behavior'.
  48. (1990). Gender Differences in Mathematics Performance: A Meta-Analysis'. doi
  49. (1988). Gender Differences in Verbal Ability. A Meta-Analysis'. doi
  50. (1985). Gender Identity and Its Implications for the Concepts of Masculinity and Femininity'.
  51. (1993). Gender-Related Traits and Gender Ideology: Evidence for a Multifactorial Theory'. doi
  52. (1966). Generalized Expectancies for Internal versus External Control of Reinforcement'. PUchological Mongg=hs: General and Appli 80, issue 609, Runge
  53. (1989). Handbook of Career neory.
  54. (1994). Handbook of Qualitative Research. doi
  55. (1988). High Flyers.
  56. (1992). Histoire A Luxembourg. Hatier, Vinnicombe S.
  57. (1984). How Large are Gender Dfferences in Aggression? A Developmental Meta-Analysis'. DevelgRmental Psychdggy,
  58. (1988). How Women Manage'. ! raining,
  59. (1962). Human Behavior and Social Processes, Ed. Rose A. M :. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London. 'A Systematic Summary of Symbolic Interaction Theory'.
  60. (1962). Human Behavior and Social Processes. Routledge & Kegan Paul,
  61. (1994). IM Women in Management: Current Research Issues, (Eds) DaWdson MJ and Burke RJ:. Paul Chapman Ltd., London. 'Women as Managerial Leaders'.
  62. (1980). IM Women's Lives: New Theory, Research,
  63. (1985). Images of Masculinity and Femininity: A Reconceptualization'.
  64. (1982). In A Different Voice: Psychological 7heory and Women's Development. doi
  65. (1989). IN: Handbook of Career Theory, doi
  66. (1991). IN: Symbolic Interactionism: Volume 1: Foundations
  67. (1991). IN. - Measures of Personality and Social Psychological Attitudes, doi
  68. (1987). IN. Sex and Gender: Review of Personality and
  69. (1987). IN. Sex Differences in Social BehaWor: A Social Role Interpretation, doi
  70. (1994). IN., Women in Management: Current Research Issues, (Fds) Datddson MJ and Burke RJ:. Paul Chapman Ltd., London. 'Managerial Sex Typing: A Persistent and Pervasive Barrier to Women's Opportunities'. -ý
  71. (1976). Internal-external Control as Contributor and Outcome of Work Experience'. doi
  72. (1986). International Dimensions of Organizational Behavior. doi
  73. (1975). Introduction to Qualitative Research Methods: A Phenomenological Approach to the Social Sciences. doi
  74. (1994). Investigating the "Glass Ceiling" Phenomenon: An Empirical Study of Actual Promotions to Top Management'. doi
  75. (1993). Luxembourg :A Multinational Financial Centre. doi
  76. (1964). Major Trends in Symbolic Interaction Theory in the Past Twenty-five Years'. doi
  77. (1971). Male Managers' Attitudes toward Working Women'. doi
  78. (1968). Managerial Attitudes and Performance. doi
  79. (1988). Managerial Job Change: Men and Women in Transition. doi
  80. (1990). Managing Lives - Corporate Women and Social Change. doi
  81. (1980). Masculine Instrumentality and ' Feminine Expressiveness: Their Relationships with Sex Role Attitudes and Behaviors'. doi
  82. (1978). Masculinity and Femininity., Yheir Psychological Dimensions, Correlates andAntecedents. doi
  83. (1973). Masculinity-Femkinity-. An Exception to a Famous Dictum Psychological Bulletin 80,5,389407. doi
  84. (1983). Masculinity, Femininity, and Androgyny Viewed and Assessed as Distinct Concepts'. doi
  85. (1986). Masculinity, Femininity, and Androgyny- A Methodological and 7heoretical Critique'. doi
  86. (1984). Masculinity, Femininity, and GenderRelated Traits: A Conceptual Analysis and Critique of Current Research'. doi
  87. (1991). Measures ofPersonality and Psychological Attitudes. doi
  88. (1980). Men and Women as Managers: A Significant Case of No Significant Difference'. Organizational Dygamics doi
  89. (1977). Men and Women of the Corporation. Basic Books, doi
  90. (1979). Methodsfor the Social Sciences: A Handbookfor Students and Non-Specialists.
  91. (1985). Motivation of Managers: Is Gender a Factor? '. PUchology of Women Quarteft
  92. (1983). Motivational Orientation of Overachieving and Underachieving Elementary School Children'.
  93. (1985). Moving Up: A Test of the Person Organizationcentered and Interactionist Perspectives'. Acadmy of Mana&LrUent Best PgRer
  94. (1966). ne Duality ofHuman Edstence.
  95. (1979). Negative and Positive Components of Psychological Masculinity and Femininity and their Relationships to Self-reports of Neurotic and Acting-out Behaviors'. doi
  96. (1979). On Assessing "Androgyny". Sex Roles, doi
  97. (1989). Organising for Cultural Diversity'. doi
  98. (1992). Organizational Behaviour and National Cultures'. doi
  99. (1994). Patterns of Differential Assimilation and Acculturation for Women in Business Organizations'. Human Relations, doi
  100. (1977). Pgper presented at Association of Teachers of Management Conference: The Training and Devel9pment Needs of Women Managers,
  101. (1975). Power: ne Inner Experience.
  102. (1994). Predicting Helping Behaviors: The Role of Gender and Instrumental/Expressive Self-Schemata'. doi
  103. (1985). Psychology and Gender. doi
  104. (1987). Psychology at Work. doi
  105. (1990). PsycholoU of Women in Management: A Distinct Feminine Leadership'.
  106. (1988). Quantity and Quality in Social Research. doi
  107. (1992). Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement (New Edition). doi
  108. (1994). Rangfolge der Luxemburger Banken nach dern Umfang ffirer Bilanzsumme'.
  109. (1975). Ratings of Self and Peers on Sex Role Attributes and Their Relation to Self-Esteem and Conceptions of Masculinity and Femininity'. doi
  110. (1994). Research Note: Hofstede's Consequences: A Study of Reviews, Citations and Replications'. Organization Studies, doi
  111. (1993). Research Training Course notes. Cranfield School of Management,
  112. (1990). rokens and Glass Ceilings": The Real Issues of "Minorities" in Organisations'. doi
  113. (1994). Sage Publications, London. 'Competing Paradigms in Qualitative Research'.
  114. (1994). Sage Publications, London. 'Using Computers in Qualitative Research'.
  115. (1977). Self-efficacy. Toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioral Change'. doi
  116. (1987). Sex and Gender. ý Revdew ofPersonality and Social PsycholoSD,. Lawrence Erlbaum,
  117. (1977). Sex Differences in Cognitive Functioning, Personality Characteristics, and Socialization Experiences: Implications for Educational Policy'. ftort to the Presidents of Smith. Welleslgy and Mt.
  118. (1986). Sex Differences in Leadership: How Real Are They?. doi
  119. (1987). Sex Differences in Social Behatdor :A Social Role Interpretation. Lawrence Erlbaum, doi
  120. (1992). Sex Differences in the Incidence and Evaluation of .! Q-U Participative Leader Behaviour'. doi
  121. (1981). Sex Discrimination against Women in Initial Placement Decisions: A Laboratory Investigation'. doi
  122. (1983). Sex Role Orientation and Self-Esteem: A Critical Meta-anal ic , Yt Review'.
  123. (1992). Shattering the Glass Ceiling - The Woman Manager. doi
  124. (1989). Should Women Managers Have to Act Eke, doi
  125. (1986). Social Forces Shape Math Attitudes and Performance'. doi
  126. (1969). Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method. doi
  127. (1991). Symbolic Interactionism: Volume 1: Foundations and History.
  128. (1966). The Adolescent Experience. doi
  129. (1994). The Art and Politics of Interpretation'. doi
  130. (1990). The Best New Managers Will Listen, Motivate, Support: Isn't That Just Like a Woman?. Working Woman,
  131. (1997). The Black and Ethnic Minority Woman Manager: Cracking the Concrete Ceiling.
  132. (1965). The Challenge of Youth. doi
  133. (1983). The Cultural Diversity of Western Conceptions of Management'.
  134. (1975). The Displaced, Uncomfortable Entrepreneurs'. PUchology--Toda
  135. (1991). The Essence ofStatisticsfor Business.
  136. (1990). The Female Advantage: Women's Ways of Leadership. doi
  137. (1990). The Guildford Press, London. 'Sex, Gender, and the Individual'.
  138. (1982). The Impact of Sex-Role Orientation on Self-Esteem in Early Adolescence'. doi
  139. (1979). The Making ofSymbolic Interactionism.
  140. (1978). The Managerial Woman. Marion Boyars, doi
  141. (1974). The Measurement of Psychological Androgyny'. doi
  142. (1989). The Second Shift., Working Parents and the Revolution at Home. Viking, doi
  143. (1978). The Sex Structuring of Organizations: A Search fbr Possible Causes'. doi
  144. (1994). Understanding Social Aeory. doi
  145. (1990). Ways Women Lead'. Harvard Business Review November-December,
  146. (1996). Wives of the Organisation'.
  147. (1974). Woman, Culture and Society. doi
  148. (1987). Women and Employment'.
  149. (1988). Women andMen in Management.
  150. (1979). Women as Effective Managers: a Strategic Model for Overcoming the Barriers'. Human Resource Manag 7,18-25. doi
  151. (1988). Women as Managers: What They Can Offer to Organizations'. OWlizational L)ynamics, doi
  152. (1990). Women Changing Work. doi
  153. (1994). Women in Management: Current Research Issues. doi
  154. (1972). Women in the Work Force. doi
  155. (1982). Women in the Workplace. Aubum House,
  156. (1988). Women Managers: Changing Organizational Cultures.
  157. (1984). Women Managers: Travellers in a Male World. doi
  158. (1991). Women of Influence, Women of Vision: A CrossGenerational Study ofLeaders and Social Change. Jossey-Bass Publishers,
  159. (1989). Women ofEurope Supplements.
  160. (1985). Women, Gender and Social Psychology. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, doi
  161. (1992). Women's Career Development.
  162. (1980). Women's Lives : doi
  163. (1985). Women's Reality., An Emerging Female System in a nite Male Society (20 edition).
  164. (1993). X, European Women
  165. (1965). X, The Challenge of Youth,
  166. (1974). Xý Woman, Culture and Society, (Eds) Rosaldo MZ and Lamphere L:. doi
  167. (1990). You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men in Conversation. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.