Location of Repository

Soccer referee decision-making: ‘Shall I blow the whistle?'

By Andrew M. Lane, Alan M. Nevill, Nahid S. Ahmad and Nigel J. Balmer


Evidence points to the existence of a home advantage effect in soccer with referees giving more\ud decisions to the home team being a plausible explanation for this effect. The purpose of the present study\ud was to use qualitative methods to explore the factors that influence experienced referees when making\ud decisions. Five experienced referees volunteered to participate in semi-structured interviews of 30-40\ud minutes duration. Examples of questions/probes included ‘Are there times when it is difficult to make a\ud decision on whether there was a foul or not? When? Why?’ and ‘Do you worry about making the wrong /\ud unpopular decision? What affect does this have on you?’ Content analysis identified 13 inter-related\ud themes that describe four higher-order themes. The themes ‘accuracy-error’, ‘regulations’, and\ud ‘professionalism’ form a higher-order theme labeled ‘ideal-decision making’. The themes ‘opinion’,\ud ‘concentration’, and ‘control’ represent a higher-order theme labeled ‘individual factors’; ‘experience’,\ud ‘personality’, and ‘personal life’ represent a higher-order factor labeled ‘experience factors’, and crowd\ud factors, player reaction, environmental factors, and crowd interaction represent a higher-order factor\ud labeled ‘situational factors’. Findings from the present study offer some insight into difficulties and\ud coping strategies used by referees to perform consistently in professional soccer. Future research could\ud use quantitative methods to test the relative contribution of themes identified above to the decisionmaking\ud process in referees. At an applied level, practitioners should develop strategies that accelerate the\ud process of learning to cope with performance-related stressors such as the crowd noise

Topics: Soccer, Bias, Home advantage, Stress, Performance, Football, Referees
Publisher: Journal of Sports Science and Medicine
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:wlv.openrepository.com:2436/14992

Suggested articles



  1. (1998). A psychophysical study of legbefore-wicket judgements in cricket.
  2. (1980). Content Analysis; An Introduction to Its Methodology.
  3. (1999). Crowd influence on decisions in association football.
  4. (1999). Designing Qualitative Research.
  5. (1996). Factors associated with home advantage in English and Scottish Soccer".
  6. (2001). Home advantage in the Winter Olympics
  7. (2002). htm [Date of access:
  8. (1997). Identifying home advantage in international tennis and golf tournaments.
  9. (2006). Influence of crowd noise in soccer on soccer refereeing consistency. Paper submitted for publication.
  10. (1994). Issues of evaluation. In: Qualitative methods in psychology: A research
  11. (2003). Judging research quality: How do we recognise good research?
  12. (1998). Oculomotor movements and football’s law 11. The Lancet 351,
  13. (1990). Perceived stress, psychological burnout and paths to turnover intentions among sport officials.
  14. (1997). Personal and situational factors that predict coping strategies for acute stress among basketball referees.
  15. (1999). Re-examining coping among basketball referees following stressful events: implications for coping interventions.
  16. (1993). Sources and intensity of acute stress in adolescent and adult Australian basketball referees: A preliminary study.
  17. (1998). Sources and magnitude of perceived psychological stress in high school volleyball officials.
  18. (2002). Subjectivity and objectivity in qualitative methodology.
  19. (1992). The home advantage in sport competitions: A literature review.
  20. (2002). The influence of crowd noise and experience upon refereeing decisions in football.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.