Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The role of conservation soil management on soil and water protection at different spatial scales

By Sophie E. Cooper

Abstract

Agriculture has a direct impact on the soil environment, altering soil properties, surface characteristics and erosion risk. This has led to a move away from conventional tillage to the adoption of conservation practices, aiming to minimise soil disturbance and reduce erosion. The effectiveness of this has been shown in studies from the USA, but equivalent research in Europe is limited. The present study investigated losses of soil, water, nutrients and carbon from different tillage regimes. Two UK sites were used – Loddington (Leicestershire, on heavy clay) and Tivington (Somerset on sandy clay loam). Three cultivations were applied - conventional (deep, inversion ploughing), and two forms of conservation tillage - SOWAP (non-inversion, shallow tillage), and Farmer Preference (non-inversion, deep tillage). Treatment effects were investigated at three spatial scales, ranging from field based erosion plots (0.05 ha), to micro-plots (1.5 m2), to soil aggregate tests. Results from 2004 to 2006 showed that adoption of conservation tillage did not consistently reduce losses of soil, water, nutrient and carbon, due to high temporal variability. Notable differences were found between sites. Runoff coefficients ranged from 0.39-0.46% at Loddington, and 2.43-3.82% at Tivington. Soil losses at Loddington were below 2 t ha-1 y-1, but higher at Tivington (3.47 t ha-1 y-1). Conservation tillage led to notable changes in soil properties and surface characteristics, including a decrease in bulk density and increases in organic matter, micro-topography and residue cover. Absolute values of erosion from small scale investigations could not be extrapolated directly to field scale results. Relative treatment ranks gave better comparisons, although results were not consistent for all small scale methods, due to high levels of variability. Caution should be used when extrapolating between spatial scales. Further work is required to understand the links between temporal and spatial fluctuations in soil, surface and rainfall characteristics and erosion processes

Publisher: National Soil Resources Institute
Year: 2006
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/1775
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2006). (in preparation). The effect of simulated fire on soil aggregate stability. Paper submitted to the European Journal of Soil Science,
  2. (2001). 1 World Congress on Conservation Agriculture: A Worldwide Challenge [online]. Madrid (Spain), Conservation Agriculture: for a better environment. Available from: http://www.ecaf.org/Congress/Report.htm
  3. (1967). A classification of soil aggregates based on their coherence in water. doi
  4. (1962). A compact rotary sieve and the importance of dry sieving in physical soil analysis. doi
  5. (1936). A direct method of aggregate analysis of soil and a study of the physical nature of erosion losses. doi
  6. (2004). A history of research on the link between (micro) aggregates, soil biota, and soil organic matter dynamics. doi
  7. (1988). A model of the effects of tillage-induced soil surface roughness on erosion. In: Tillage and traffic in crop production,
  8. (2000). A multi-scale approach to predicting soil erosion on cropland using empirical and physically based soil erosion models in a Geographic Information System. doi
  9. (1965). A review of rainfall simulators. doi
  10. (1979). Accelerated erosion of arable soils in the United Kingdom by rainfall and runoff.
  11. (2005). Aggregate breakdown dynamics under rainfall compared with aggregate stability measurements. doi
  12. (1997). Aggregate stability and assessment of soil crustability and erodibility: II. Application to humic loamy soils with various organic carbon contents. doi
  13. (1996). Aggregate stability and assessment of soil crustability and erodibility. 1. Theory and methodology. doi
  14. (1986). Aggregate stability and size distribution. doi
  15. (1993). Aggregate stability and soil microbial processes in a soil with different cultivation. doi
  16. (1986). Aggregate structure and carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus in native and cultivated soils. doi
  17. (2002). Aggregation, fragmentation and structural stability measurements. doi
  18. (1997). Agricultural soils as a sink to mitigate CO2 emissions. doi
  19. (2005). Allerton Project [online].
  20. (2006). An assessment of conservation tillage in the EU. Unpublished M.Sc. thesis,
  21. (1985). An improved method of aggregate stability measurement. doi
  22. (2001). An improved rainfall erosivity index obtained from experimental interrill soil losses in soils with a Mediterranean climate. doi
  23. (2001). An overview of some tillage impacts on earthworm population abundance and diversity – implications for functioning in soils. doi
  24. (2001). Analysis of sources of variability of runoff volume in a 40 plot experiment using a numerical model. doi
  25. (1988). Approached to modelling the effects of vegetation on soil erosion by water.
  26. (1985). Assessment of soil surface sealing and crusting. Flanders Research Centre for Soil Erosion and Soil Conservation, doi
  27. (1991). Assessment of the effects of the biota on soil structure: methods for assessing the effects of biota on soil structure. doi
  28. (1988). Assessment of the interrill and rill contributions to total soil loss from an upland field plot. doi
  29. (2006). Boscastle and North Cornwall Floods [online]. Wadebridge, North Cornwall District Council. Available from:
  30. (2003). CAP reform – a long-term perspective for sustainable agriculture [online]. Brussels (Belgium),
  31. (2005). Carbon loses from soils across England and Wales doi
  32. (2005). Case Study 1 – Reduced cultivation with disc harrows or direct drill [online]. Chester, Soil Management Initiative. Available from:
  33. (2006). Case Study 4 – Progressive adoption of reduced cultivation [online]. Chester, Soil Management Initiative. Available from:
  34. (2005). Changes in soil enzyme activity, fertility, aggregation and C sequestration mediated - 278 -by conservation tillage practices and water regime in a maize field. doi
  35. (1952). Compact wet sieving apparatus for soil aggregate analysis. doi
  36. (2005). Composition of organic matter fractions for explaining wettability of three forest soils. doi
  37. (1995). Conservation Tillage and Water Quality [online].
  38. (1994). Conserving soil resources: European perspectives. Page 94-104. Oxon:
  39. (2006). County Council. Available from: http://www.somerset.gov.uk/somerset/ete/pcp/
  40. (2001). Crust development in relation to vegetation and agricultural practice on erosion susceptible, dispersive clay soils from central and southern Italy. doi
  41. (1992). Crusting, runoff, and erosion response to soil water content and successive rainfalls. doi
  42. (2006). Dakota State University. Available from: doi
  43. (1975). Determination of the structural stability class of English and Welsh soils, using a water-coherance test. doi
  44. (1981). Drop testing aggregate stability of some soils near doi
  45. (2000). Dynamics and scale in simulating erosion by water. doi
  46. (1981). Effect of crop residue on soil loss from continuous row cropping. doi
  47. (1993). Effect of cultivation and raindrop impact on the surface hydraulic properties of an Alfisol under wheat. doi
  48. (2005). Effect of rainfall and tillage direction on the evolution of surface crusts, soil hydraulic properties and runoff generation for a sandy loam soil. doi
  49. (1971). Effect of row grades and tillage systems on soil and water losses.
  50. (2006). Effect of soil aggregate size on infiltration and erosion characteristics. doi
  51. (2005). Effects of erosion patterns on nutrient loss following deforestation on the Loess Plateau of China. doi
  52. (2004). Effects of long-term winter wheat, summer fallow residue and nutrient management on field hydrology for a silt loam in north-central Oregon. doi
  53. (2001). Effects of rock fragment cover on soil infiltration, interrill runoff and erosion. doi
  54. (2004). Effects of soil conservation measures on erosion rates and crop productivity on subtropical Ultisols in Yunnan Province, doi
  55. (1984). Effects of surface management on runoff and soil erosion from some plots at Mlingano, doi
  56. (1994). Effects of tillage and rainfall on soil surface roughness and properties. doi
  57. (2001). Environment 2010: Our Future, Our Choice. The Sixth Environment Action Programme 2001-10. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities,
  58. (1975). Environment Research Council)., doi
  59. (2006). Environmental Stewardship – Latest news [online]. London, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Available from: http://www.defra.gov.uk/erdp/schemes/es/default.htm
  60. (1997). Erosion and sediment characteristics of cultivated forest soils as affected by the mechanical stability of aggregates. doi
  61. (2006). Erosion rates evaluated by the 137Cs technique and direct measurements on long-term runoff plots under tropical conditions. doi
  62. (2006). European Commission on the Environment. Available from: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/soil/index.htm [Accessed
  63. (2002). Evaluation of Four Conservation Tillage Methods in the Sugar Beet Crop.
  64. (1993). Extent, frequency and rates of rilling of arable land in localities in England and Wales. In: Wicherek, S. (ed) Farm land erosion: in temperate plains environment and hills. doi
  65. (2003). Factors affecting runoff and soil erosion: plot-level soil loss monitoring for assessing sustainability of forest management. doi
  66. Factors affecting the use of conservation tillage in the United States.
  67. (1993). Field measurement of soil erosion and runoff.
  68. (2001). Field soil aggregate stability kit for soil quality and rangeland health evaluations. doi
  69. Field studies of sediment transport by overland flow. doi
  70. (2005). Field testing of mitigation options -
  71. (2000). Field-scale run-off and erosion in relation to topsoil aggregates stability in three tropical regions (Benin, Cameroon, Mexico). doi
  72. (2004). Fund of Friends of Conservation Agriculture [online]. Brussels (Belgium), European Conservation Agriculture Federation. Available from: http://www.ecaf.org/FOCA.htm
  73. (2002). High-energy-moisture-characteristic aggregate stability as a predictor for seal formation. doi
  74. (2004). Impacts of land management on fluxes of trace greenhouse gases. doi
  75. in press. Sources and processes of measurement variability of experimental soil erosion field plots in semiarid Mediterranean conditions. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, doi
  76. (2004). Indicators for pan-European assessment and monitoring of soil erosion by water. doi
  77. (2005). Influence of simulated rainfall on physical properties of a conventionally tilled loess soil. doi
  78. (1984). Influence of tillage systems on soil physical parameters and infiltration after planting.
  79. (2002). Influence of time on measurement results of erosion plot studies. doi
  80. (2003). Information leaflet: Tap water – where does it come from and how is it made safe to drink? [online]. London, Drinking Water Inspectorate. - 267 -Available from: http://www.dwi.gov.uk/consumer/faq/tapwater.htm
  81. (2006). Interactions between soil microbial communities, erodibility and tillage practices. Unpublished PhD thesis,
  82. (2003). Long-term straw management effects on yields of sequential wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) crops in clay and silty clay loam soils in England. doi
  83. (2006). Management of sediment production and prevention in river catchments: A matter of scale? doi
  84. (2005). Managing erosion and water quality in agricultural watersheds by small detention ponds. doi
  85. (1969). Mathematical simulation of the process of soil erosion by water. doi
  86. (1949). Mean weight diameter of soil aggregates as a statistical index of aggregation. doi
  87. (1988). Measurement of soil aggregate settling velocities, II. Sensitivity to sample moisture content and implications for studies of structural stability. doi
  88. (1941). Measurement of the fall velocity of water drop and rain drops.
  89. (2006). Measuring soil erosion by field plots: Understanding the sources of variation. doi
  90. (1992). Mechanisms of overland-flow generation and sediment production on loamy and sandy soils with and without rock fragments.
  91. (1965). Meteorological drought. doi
  92. (1964). Methods of reducing soil crusting to increase cotton seedling emergence. doi
  93. (1970). Modified rotary sieve for improved accuracy. doi
  94. (2006). National Soil Erosion Research Lab (Agricultural Research Service, United States Department of Agriculture). Available from: http://topsoil.nserl.purdue.edu/nserlweb/weppmain/
  95. (2006). Nature & Biodiversity - Habitats Directive [online]. Brussels (Belgium), European Commission on the Environment. Available from: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/nature_conservation/eu_nature_legis lation/habitats_directive/index_en.htm [Accessed 30
  96. (2006). Needles : Teflon [online].
  97. (2003). NITRATES – Reducing Water Pollution from Agriculture [online]. London, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Available from: http://www.defra.gov.uk/ENVIRONMENT/water/quality/nitrate/nitrogen.ht m
  98. (2006). Nitrates – Reducing water pollution from agriculture. Nitrate Vulnerable Zones in England [online]. London, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. Available from: http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/water/quality/nitrate/nvz.htm
  99. (2005). Organic carbon ranges in arable soils of England and Wales. Soil Use and doi
  100. (1982). Organic matter and water-stable aggregates in soils. doi
  101. (2000). Organic matter influence on clay wettability and soil aggregate stability. doi
  102. (1975). Orientation of clay particles as it relates to crusting of soils. doi
  103. (2003). Overview of the linkages between agricultural activities, water pollution, and water use. In: OECD expert meeting on agricultural water quality and water use indicator,
  104. (2004). Personal communication. Laboratory for Experimental Geomorphology,
  105. (2005). Personal communication. School of Applied Sciences,
  106. (2004). Phosphorus mobilisation from European soils by overland flow. Unpublished PhD thesis,
  107. (1990). Phosphorus transport in agricultural runoff: the role of soil erosion.
  108. (2006). Practical soil protection and stabilization in Mediterranean viticulture. Unpublished MPhil Thesis.
  109. (1998). Predicting erosion and sediment yield at the catchment scale. In: Penning de
  110. (1978). Predicting rainfall erosion losses: a guide to conservation planning.
  111. (2005). Prediction of sub-tropical storm soil losses from field plot studies. doi
  112. (1930). Properties of Soils Which Influence Erosion. doi
  113. (1999). Quantification of runoff in laboratoryscale chambers. doi
  114. (1928). Questions on soil structure: II. Aggregate analysis as a method for determining soil structure.
  115. (2002). Rainfall and tillage effect on soil structure after alfalfa conversion to maize on a clay loam soil in New York. doi
  116. (1983). Rainfall simulator for tillage research in the tropics. doi
  117. (1990). Rates of change of soil structure under different cropping systems. doi
  118. (1954). Report 2: 77-122. In: Low A.J.,
  119. (2004). Reports of the Technical Working Groups Established under the Thematic Strategy for Soil Protection.
  120. (1991). Resistance to overland flow on desert pavement and its implications for sediment transport modelling. doi
  121. (2003). Rill and gully development during an extreme winter runoff event in Norway. doi
  122. (1951). River channel roughness.
  123. (1994). Rock fragments in top soils: significance and processes. doi
  124. (1996). Runoff and sediment loss from three tillage systems under simulated rainfall. doi
  125. (2005). Runoff and sediment losses from rough and smooth soil surfaces in a laboratory experiment. doi
  126. (1999). Runoff and soil erosion as affected by plastic mulch in a Hawaiian pineapple field. doi
  127. (1985). Runoff results from natural and simulated rainfall for tillage systems. doi
  128. (2004). Scale effect in USLE and WEPP application for soil erosion computation from three Sicilian basins. doi
  129. (2004). Scale effect on runoff from experimental plots to catchments in agricultural areas in Normandy. doi
  130. (2002). Sediment carbon concentration and transport from small watersheds under various conservation tillage practices. doi
  131. (2006). Seven Environmental Thematic Strategies [online]. Brussels (Belgium), European Commission on the Environment. Available from: http://ec.europa.eu/environment/newprg/strategies_en.htm
  132. (1993). Simple methods of characterizing erosive rainfall with reference to the South Downs, southern England. doi
  133. (1979). Soil aggregate stability tests for the geomorphologist.
  134. (1984). Soil and water losses as affected by tillage and manure application. doi
  135. (2006). Soil carbon losses by water erosion: Experimentation and modelling at field and national scales in the UK. doi
  136. (1996). Soil characteristics and aggregate stability. doi
  137. (1984). Soil cohesion as affected by time and water content. doi
  138. (1972). Soil conservation.
  139. (1981). Soil conservation. 2 nd ed.
  140. (1995). Soil conservation. 3 rd ed. Batsford Limited: London.
  141. (1974). Soil detachment from clods by rainfall: effects of wind, mulch cover and essential soil moisture. doi
  142. (1994). Soil Ecology. UK: doi
  143. (1975). Soil erodibility as determined by the raindrop technique. doi
  144. (1995). Soil erosion and conservation. doi
  145. (2005). Soil erosion and conservation. 3 rd ed.
  146. (1986). Soil erosion and its control.
  147. (1994). Soil erosion and its impacts in England and Wales. Friends of the Earth: London Evans,
  148. (1999). Soil erosion at three experimental sites doi
  149. (1993). Soil erosion on road shoulders. Thesis (PhD).
  150. (1976). Soil erosion problems on an Alfisol in western Nigeria and their control. IITA Monograph No.1.
  151. (1989). Soil erosion, soil conservation and agricultural policy for arable land in the U.K. doi
  152. (2005). Soil infiltration, runoff and sediment yield from a shallow soil with varied stone cover and intensity of rain. doi
  153. (2006). Soil invertebrates and ecosystem services. doi
  154. (2004). Soil management: problems and solutions. doi
  155. (2003). Soil physical characteristics and chickpea yield responses to tillage treatments. doi
  156. (1994). Soil science: methods and applications. London: Prentice Hall SCC,
  157. (2000). Soil Structure and Soil Organic Matter: II. A Normalized Stability Index and the Effect of Mineralogy. doi
  158. (1993). Soil surface densification under simulated high intensity rainfall. doi
  159. (1997). Soil survey field handbook: describing and sampling soil profiles, 3 rd ed.
  160. (2006). Soil wettability relationships with soil organic carbon and aggregate stability [online]. doi
  161. (2004). Soil wetting and texture effects on aggregate stability, seal formation and erosion. doi
  162. Soil, the hidden resource: Towards an Environment Agency strategy for soil protection, management and restoration: A consultation document. Environment Agency.
  163. (2004). Soils as carbon sinks: the global context. doi
  164. (2000). Soils: their properties and management. 2nd ed. Oxford:
  165. (1951). Some applications of water drop stability testing of tropical soils of Puerto Rico. doi
  166. (1990). Spatial and seasonal variations of soil erodibility. Unpublished PhD thesis,
  167. (1997). Stabilization of aggregates by the microbial biomass as affected by soil texture and type. doi
  168. (1994). Structure breakdown on wetting. In: doi
  169. (1944). Studies of raindrop erosion. doi
  170. (1935). Studies on the morphological activity of rivers as illustrated by the River Fyris. doi
  171. (1994). Surface seal development under simulated rainfall on an actively eroding surface. doi
  172. (1996). The accuracy of manual runoff and sediment sampling from erosion plots.
  173. (2006). The Beaufort Scale [online]. Devon, Met Office. Available from: http://www.metoffice.com/education/secondary/students/beaufort.html
  174. (1957). The design of field experiments on soil erosion.
  175. (1954). The determination of the stability of soil crumbs. doi
  176. (1968). The development, use and efficiency of indices of soil erodibility. doi
  177. (1998). The effect of polyacrilamide based soil conditioners on structural sealing at a sub-process level. Unpublished PhD thesis,
  178. (1998). The environmental benefits and costs of conservation tillage. doi
  179. (1998). The European soil erosion model (EUROSEM): a dynamic approach for predicting sediment transport from fields and small catchments. doi
  180. The first soil action plan for England: 2004-2006. London: Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs,
  181. (1964). The flour pellet method for measuring the size of raindrops.
  182. (1990). The hydrological response of soil surfaces to rainfall as affected by cover and position of rock fragments in the top layer. doi
  183. (1995). The impact of agricultural practices on biodiversity. doi
  184. (1964). The influence of a thin water layer on waterdrop impact forces.
  185. (1965). The influence of rainfall on the mechanics of soil erosion with particular reference to Southern Rhodesia. MSc Thesis,
  186. (2002). The nature and properties of soils. 13th ed.
  187. (1943). The relation of raindrop size to intensity. doi
  188. (2001). The selective removal of phosphorus from soil: is event size important? doi
  189. The State of Soils in England and Wales. Bristol: Environmental Agency.
  190. (1954). The study of soil structure in the field and the laboratory. doi
  191. (1949). The terminal velocity of fall for water droplets in stagnant air. doi
  192. (1984). The use of high energy moisture characteristics to assess soil stability’. doi
  193. (1985). The water drop test of soil erodibility.
  194. (2004). Tillage and crop management effects on soil erosion in central Croatia. doi
  195. (2001). Tillage and nutrient source effects on surface and subsurface water quality at corn planting, doi
  196. (2001). Tillage systems and soil ecology. doi
  197. (1960). Turbidimeter technique for measuring the stability of soil aggregates in a water-glycerol mixture. doi
  198. (1999). Variability in soil erosion data from replicated plots. doi
  199. (1986). Variability of runoff and soil loss from fallow experimental plots. doi
  200. (1994). Water chemistry as a factor influencing the erosivity of simulated rain. Unpublished MSc. thesis,
  201. (1944). Water drop method of determining stability of soil structure. doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.