Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The evaluation of ground based remote sensing systems for canopy nitrogen management in winter wheat

By Jana Havránková


Nitrogen management is a crucial issue in terms of environmental and economical efficiency for winter wheat husbandry. Precision Agriculture in particular Remote Sensing, has been used to determine the variability of the crop. However, to be able to apply the required rate of nitrogen, the calibration of the data with the crop characteristics is critical. Satellite, airborne and ground based platforms are possible to use. Despite the presence of some commercial applications of the satellite and airborne techniques, the ground based systems offer advantages in terms of availability. The most common passive ground based remote sensing system in Europe is the Yara N sensor which has limitations in poor light conditions. Active sensors, using their own energy sources, are now available in the market e.g. the Crop Circle (Holland Scientific) and the Yara N sensor ALS. The aim of this work was to evaluate the active and passive ground based remote sensing systems for canopy nitrogen management in winter wheat. The work was divided into three sub-experiments. Two were conducted in Wilstead (UK) in 2005 and 2006, with the objective to determine the relationship between sensors output (NDVI) and crop (wheat) characteristics during the growing season and to evaluate their application in field management of winter wheat. The field experiment carried out in Oponice (Slovakia) in 2006 assessed three different management strategies (the real time, near real time and traditional nitrogen management). The results showed that both the active and the passive sensors determine the variability in shoot numbers and total nitrogen content of plants particularly in the early growth stages. The application of Nitrogen using these sensors in the UK saved 15kg N/ha (UK). The nitrogen saved in Slovakia was small (1.5 kg/ha). Use of the sensors enabled a reduction in nitrogen without a negative influence on yield, which increased the Nitrogen use efficiency. In addition to this there were potential environmental benefits through a 52% reduction of the residual Nitrogen in the soil in the UK. In Slovakia there was no significant overall reduction in the total nitrogen used; however, a different application rates was applied to 80% of the field. The overall cost of production in Slovakia using the sensors was increased by 5%. The cost of sensing in the UK was £11/ha which could be offset by the 15 kgN/ha reduction and a potential small increase of yield by 1%

Publisher: School of Applied Sciences
Year: 2007
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (2005). Active sensor for corn (Accessed:
  2. (1997). Adoption rates for recommended crop management practices: Implication for precision farming. In:
  3. (2002). Airborne multispectral data for quantifying leaf area index, nitrogen concentration, and photosynthetic efficiency in agriculture. Remote sensing of doi
  4. (2003). An economic analysis of the potential for precision farming in UK cereal production. doi
  5. (2005). Analyses of spaceborne hyperspectral and directional CHRIS data to deliver crop status for precision agriculture Crop variability and resulting management effects, In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision agriculture Wageningen:
  6. (2005). Applications of Spectral reflectance Techniques in Northern European Cereal Production: A Review. doi
  7. Barnes, E.M.(1997) Opportunities and Limitations for Image-Based Remote Sensing in Precision Crop Management. Remote sensing of Environment, doi
  8. (2003). Calibration Methodology for Mapping Within-field Crop Variability using Remote Sensing. doi
  9. (2000). Canopy management in winter wheat. Topic Sheet No. 40 Home Grown Cereals Authority,
  10. (2004). Changes in spectral reflectance of wheat leaves in response to specific macronutrient deficiency. doi
  11. (1999). Cielené (presné) poľnohospodárstvo ako nová etapa vývoja technizácie a intelektualizácie poľnohospodárstva. Vytváření ziskového zemědělství,
  12. (2004). Collecting spectral data over cropland vegetation using machine-positioning versus handpositioning of the sensor. doi
  13. (1999). Cost/benefit analysis of introduction site-specific management on a commercial farm In: Stafford,
  14. (2005). Crop variability and resulting management effects,
  15. (2002). Deriving green area index and canopy chlorophyll density of winter wheat from spectral reflectance data. Remote sensing of doi
  16. (2003). Developing strategies for Spatially Variable Nitrogen Application in Cereals. Part II: doi
  17. (1983). Diurnal Patterns of Wheat Spectral Reflectances. doi
  18. (1999). E.(1996) Nitrogen Management for Winter Wheat: Principles and Recommendations. Virginia Cooperative Extension PUBLICATION 424-026
  19. (2007). Ecologically-Based Soil and Crop Management Systems for Sustainable Agriculture (Accessed:
  20. (1997). Economic and environmental evaluation of variable rate nitrogen fertilizer applications using a biophysical model.
  21. (2001). Economic aspects of precision agriculture: An economic assessment of different site-specific N-fertilization approaches. In:
  22. (1986). Effect of Dew on Canopy Reflectance and temperature. doi
  23. (1986). Effect of Nitrogen fertilization on Growth and Reflectance Characteristics of Winter Wheat. doi
  24. (1999). Engineering technologies for precision farming. In: USDAAgricultural research service (Accessed:
  25. (2000). Estimating Corn Leaf Chlorophyll Concentration from Leaf and Canopy Reflectance. Remote sensing of doi
  26. (2004). Estimating Tiller Density and Leaf Area Index of Winter Wheat using Spectral Reflectance and Ultrasonic Sensing Techniques. doi
  27. (2005). Evaluating the benefits from precision agriculture: the economics of meeting traceability requirements and environmental targets. In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision agriculture 2005.Wageningen: doi
  28. (2005). Evaluation of mapping and online nitrogen fertiliser application strategies in multiyear and multi-location static field trials for increasing nitrogen use efficiency of cereals. In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision Agriculture,
  29. (2005). Farm management pocketbook.
  30. (2007). Farmstar (Accessed:
  31. (2005). FARMSTAR: an efficient decision support tool for near real time crop management from satellite images. In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision Agriculture,
  32. (2007). Farmstar: Crop management with Spot (Accessed:
  33. (2003). Field-scale validation of a tractor based multispectral crop scanner to determine biomass and nitrogen uptake of winter wheat. 4
  34. (2005). GreenSeeker (Accessed:
  35. (2005). Hydro N sensor,
  36. (2003). Hydro N senzor. doi
  37. (2005). Implemantation of the site-specific fertilizers application and manager knowledge requirements. In: Agricultural engineering for a better world: XVI. CIGR world congress,
  38. (2005). In-Field Assessment of Single Leaf Nitrogen Status by Spectral Reflectance Measurements. Precision Agriculture, doi
  39. (2000). In:
  40. (1987). Influence of topography and sensor view anles on NIR/red ratio and greenness vegetation indices of wheat. doi
  41. (2000). Introductory Remote Sensing Principles and Concepts. doi
  42. (2005). Laser – Inducted Chlorophyll Fluorescence Measurements for Detecting the Nitrogen Status of Wheat canopies. doi
  43. (2003). Late-Season Prediction of Wheat Grain Yieldand Grain Protein. Communication in soil science and plant analysis 34, doi
  44. (2006). Leading Farmers (2006) Yara N senzor
  45. (2006). Methods for controlling crop inputs for Northern Ireland conditions. Unpublished MSc by Research,
  46. (2005). Monitorovanie vplyvu variabilného hnojenia priemyselnými hnojivami a jeho ekonomické zhodnotenie. In: Využitie technológie diaľkového prieskumu ako nástroja pre podporu rozhodovania v hnojení poľných plodín dusíkom. In:
  47. (1992). Multi-site Analyses of Specral-Biolhysical Data for Wheat. Remote sensing of doi
  48. (2006). N Sensor ALS - variable rate nitrogen around the clock (Accessed
  49. (2007). N-sensor ALS. doi
  50. (2005). Nitrátová direktíva na Slovensku. In: Agrochémia,
  51. (1998). Optimalizácia výživy pšenice ozimnej (Optimalisation of winter wheat nutrition).
  52. (2003). Optimisation of oblique-view remote measurement of crop Nuptake under changing irradiance conditions.
  53. (2005). Optimum waveband selection for determining the nitrogen uptake in winter wheat by active remote sensing. In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision Agriculture,
  54. (2005). P.C.H.(2005) Vehicle mounted sensors for estimating tiller density and leaf area index (LAI) of winter wheat Crop variability and resulting management effects, In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision agriculture Wageningen:
  55. (2006). Passive vs active sensing. (Accessed: 19.4.2007) University at Silsoe Jana Havránková,
  56. (2004). Performance of a Crop Canopy Reflectance Sensor to Assess Chlorophyll Content (Accessed: 15.2.2005) University at Silsoe Jana Havránková,
  57. (2003). Potential of airborne hyperspectral remote sensing to detect nitrogen deficiency and weed infestation in corn. doi
  58. (2003). Precision agriculture – economic aspects. In: Precision Agriculture doi
  59. (2007). Precision agriculture for arable crops In:
  60. (2003). Precision Agriculture: Changing the face of Farming. In: Geotimes (Accessed:
  61. (1999). Precision farming
  62. (2002). Precision farming approaches to small-farm agriculture. Agro –Chemicals report (Accessed: 29.11.2003)
  63. (2002). Precision farming of cereal crops: A five-year experiment to develop management guidelines. doi
  64. (2003). Precision farming of cereal crops: a review of a six year experiment to develop management guidelines. doi
  65. (2002). Precision farming of cereals practical guidelines and crop nutrition. Home Grown Cereals Authority,
  66. (2003). Precision Farming or Convenience Agriculture. In: doi
  67. (1997). Precision farming techniques for sustainable agriculture. In:
  68. (2000). Precision farming: seed – rate and nitrogen interactions.
  69. (1995). Predicting Nitrogen and Chlophyll Content and Concentration from Reflectance Spectra (400-2500nm) at Leaf and Canopy Scales. Remote sensing of doi
  70. (2005). Projektovanie výrobných systémov. Výpočty a analýzy.
  71. (2003). Radiometric Field Measurements of Maize for estimating Soil and Plant Nitrogen. doi
  72. (2003). Real-time Measures of Canopy Size as a Basis for Spatially Varying Nitrogen Applications to Winter Wheat son at Different Seed Rates. doi
  73. (2003). Reflectance measurement of canopy biomass and nitrogen status in heat crops using normalized difference vegetation indices and partial least squares regression. Remote sensing of doi
  74. (2002). Relationships between defoliation, leaf area index, canopy reflectance, and forage yield in the alfalfa-leaf spot pathosystem. doi
  75. (2007). Remote sensing figures (Accessed:
  76. (2000). Remote Sensing of Biomass And Yield of Winter Wheat under Different Nitrogen Supplies. doi
  77. (2004). Report to the Northern Ireland Precision Agriculture project management board.
  78. (2007). Scientific (2005a) Crop Circle ACS 210 Plant Canopy Reflectance Sensor - Instruction Manual (Accessed: 20.2.2005) University at Silsoe Jana Havránková,
  79. Scientific (2005c) Crop Circle Evaluation Package (Accessed:
  80. (2005). Selection of optimum Reflectance Ratios for Estimating Leaf Nitrogen and Chlorophyll Concentrations of Field-row Cotton. Agronomy Journal 97, 89 -98Cranfield University at Silsoe Jana Havránková, doi
  81. (2002). Sensor-based Precision Chemical Application Systems. doi
  82. (2003). Site-specific Crop Response to Soil Variability in an Upland Field: Master thesis. In: Publications about precision farming(Accessed: 4.
  83. (1999). Site-specific farming. In:
  84. (1983). Soils of England and Wales.
  85. (1969). Soils of the Luton and Bedford district: a reconnaissance survey. The survey.
  86. (2007). SOYL sense doi
  87. (2002). Spatio-temporal quality of Precision farming Applications. In: doi
  88. (2004). Spectral measurements at different spatial scales in potato: relating leaf, plant and canopy nitrogen status. doi
  89. (2002). Study on line imaging spectroscopy as a tool for nitrogen diagnostics in Precision Farming : PhD thesis. In: Publications about precision farming (Accessed:
  90. (1985). Sun-angle and canopy-architecture effects on the spectral reflectance of six wheat cultivars. doi
  91. (2005). Temporal prediction of nitrogen status in winter wheat under the influence of water deficiency using spectral and thermal information. Crop variability and resulting management effects, In: Stafford, J.V.: Precision agriculture Wageningen:
  92. (2004). The Centre for Precision Farming doi
  93. (1997). The wheat growth guide to improve husbandry decision. Home Grown Cereals Authority,
  94. (2005). Using ground – based multispectral radiometry to detect stress in wheat caused by greenbug (Homoptera> Aphididae) infestation. doi
  95. (1996). Variable Rate Application Equipment for Precision Farming (Accessed: doi
  96. (2004). Variable Rate Nitrogen Fertilisation of Winter Wheat Based on a Crop Density Sensor. Precision Agriculture, doi
  97. (1974). Vegetation Canopy Reflectance. Remote sensing of doi
  98. (2005). Vlastné náklady a výsledky hospodárenia poľnohospodárskych podnikov v SR za rok 2005. Bratislava: Výskumný ústav ekonomiky poľnohospodárstva a potravinárstva,
  99. (2007). Vplyv priestorovo diferencovaných vsetupov na efektívnosť výroby poľných plodín (Effects of site-specific inputs on crop production efficiency) PhD Thesis.
  100. (2000). Výživa a hnojenie poľných plodín.

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.