Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Project sponsor competence in the UK public sector: A systematic review

By Jonathan Lupson

Abstract

This thesis reviews the literature on project sponsorship, competence and accountability in the public sector. It adopts a systematic review methodology, which aims to find, evaluate, analyse and synthesize literature on a transparent, replicable basis. Based on a set of keywords derived from a scoping study and practitioner inputs, a series of keyword searches were conducted on a number of databases. The literature found was evaluated for relevance and rigour against a set of specified source, content and quality criteria. I developed new content criteria in response to new uses of keywords in the literature. I also used the reference lists in the material that passed all the criteria to find further literature, which I also reviewed for rigour and relevance against the source, content and quality criteria. Systematic review is therefore a deductive process, which changed my understanding of the research subject form a general one to a more specific one. I found project sponsorship to be a common role in many areas where project management is used. My synthesis of the literature suggested that the role is a powerful, risk-taking one, requiring leadership and ownership. Competence is a divided , ambiguous concept, with current approaches limited by virtue of their rational, dualistic ontology. Accountability is fundamental to any understanding the role of the project sponsor in the public sector, but is a difficult, changing concept, capable of being viewed from either a process or an organizational perspective. I found significant research gaps in the project sponsorship literature. It has been the subject of little direct research. Whilst there is some understanding of the role in relation to the project, the wider aspects of the role and what may constitute competence in the the role are fertile areas for further research.Masters by Researc

Publisher: Cranfield University
Year: 2003
OAI identifier: oai:dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk:1826/1661
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles

Citations

  1. (2003). 16:02:45 Page 214 of 214 I have started reading the competence material: it is clear that the idea of bracketing (Husserl’s epoche) is going to mean trying to forget or clear my mind of the literature prior to carrying out the field research.
  2. (2003). 18:10:07 Dunleavy and Hood make a point about NPM: organizations as a chain of low trust principal / agent relationships, a network of contracts linked to performance.
  3. A Heuristic Framework For Accountability of Governmental Subunits, doi
  4. (1991). A Manager's Guide to Executive Support Systems, doi
  5. (1999). A Phenomenological Perspective on Some Phenomenographic Results on Learning, Journal of Phenomenological Psychology, doi
  6. A Process Model of Internal Corporate Venturing in the Diversified Major Firm, doi
  7. (1993). A Synthesis of Current Research on Management Competencies, The Henley Management College, HWP 10/93,
  8. (1987). Accountabilities: Five Public Services, doi
  9. (1993). Accountability and Accountable Management in the UK public sector, doi
  10. (1987). Accountability in the Public Sector: Lessons from the Challenger Tragedy, doi
  11. Accountability in the Regulatory State, doi
  12. (1986). Accountable Management in British Central Government: Some Reflections on the Financial Management Initiative, Financial Accountability and Management, doi
  13. (1993). Achieving Strategic Coherence In doi
  14. (1986). Advanced Manufacturing Technology and Management Development, doi
  15. Agency Perspective on New Technology Champions, doi
  16. (1995). An Experimental Investigation of Factors Influencing Predicted Success of DSS Implementation, doi
  17. (1990). Approaches to Management Development in the UK, doi
  18. (1994). Are Champions Different from Non-Champions?, doi
  19. Are You Ready To Be A Change Sponsor?,
  20. (1996). Assessing AMT implementations: An empirical field study, doi
  21. Australia Program delivery Central Government Qualitative Coalition building and strategy development as facets of the performance drive in new public management.
  22. (2000). Australia Project ERP (Enterprise Qualitative An experienced ERP implementer as Page 163 of 214 Model of ERP Project Implementation,
  23. (1996). Behavior doi
  24. (1997). Beyond the frame of management competenc(i)es: towards a contextually embedded framework of managerial competence in organizations, doi
  25. (1995). Business-driven management development: developing competences which drive business performance., doi
  26. (1988). Business: Why Sponsoring Innovations May Be Hazardous To Career Health, doi
  27. (1991). Canada Leadership Innovation Qualitative Champions need to be more skilful at politics when engaged in administrative innovation compared with product innovation. Seeking permission is a lower risk route than seeking forgiveness.
  28. Canada Project Management IT Quantitative Focus is project owner in software development projects. Consultation with owner at key stages / informing owner of progress is No.1 CSF. Owner role definition not clear.
  29. Centres: Preevaluation of their Usefulness in Local Government, Creativity and Innovation Management, doi
  30. Champions and Antagonists: Relationships with R&D Project Characteristics and Management, doi
  31. (1980). Champions and Technological Innovation doi
  32. (1963). Champions for Radical New Inventions,
  33. (1984). Champions: The Kingdom of New Venture Management, doi
  34. (2000). Changing competences of public managers: Tensions in commitment, doi
  35. Comparing Accountability in the 2000 Australia Accountability Public / Private Sectors Theoretical Levels of accountability in the public sector are much greater than in the private sector, except Page 207 of 214 Public and Private Sectors, doi
  36. (1998). Competence Specificities in Organizations - A Classificatory Framework, International Studies of Management and Organization,
  37. (1995). Competence-based management development: rhetoric and reality., doi
  38. (1994). Competences as resources in firms, doi
  39. Competences for international management.,
  40. (1997). Competences in management development: challenging the myths. doi
  41. (1996). Competences: measuring the unmeasurable, Management Development Review, doi
  42. (1996). control moves from being output based to behaviour based. Control theory as the means of describing sponsor behaviour. Sponsor as controller.
  43. (2003). Conveners as champions of collaboration in the public sector: a case from South Africa, Public Administration and Development, doi
  44. Corporate Championing and Antagonism as Forms of Political Behavior: An R&D Perspective, Organization Science, doi
  45. (2002). Cracking the collaboration code, doi
  46. (1989). Creating The Managerial Portfolio: Building On Competency Approaches to Management Development, Management Education and Development, doi
  47. Cultivating the champions for strategic information systems, doi
  48. (1987). Deciding to Innovate, Ballinger Publishing Company
  49. (1997). Deconstructing deep and surface: Towards a critique of phenomenography,
  50. Determinants Of Technical Success In Product Development When Innovative Radicalness Is Considered, doi
  51. (1981). Encouraging Entrepreneurship in the Large Corporations,
  52. Environmental Scanning, Innovation Framing, And Champion Behaviour: Key Predictors Of Performance, doi
  53. Executive Information Systems: A Framework for Development and a Survey of Current Practices, doi
  54. (2000). Expert System Stalemate: A Case of Project Champion Departure, doi
  55. Factors influencing the success of management consulting projects, doi
  56. from 10 Case Studies in Innovation –
  57. (1994). From job-based to competency-based organizations, doi
  58. (2001). Gender and managerial competence: support for theories of androgyny?, doi
  59. General Practitioner The sponsor is one the 4 critical change roles. Sponsors legitimise change. Prescriptions of what the sponsor must and must not do.
  60. Getting The Measure of Management Competence, Personnel Management,
  61. (1992). Implementing Advanced Manufacturing Technologies: Rules of the Road, doi
  62. In Search of Excellence in Project Management, doi
  63. (1982). In Search of Excellence: Lessons from Americas Best Run Companies, Harper and Row doi
  64. (2001). Information Technology Competence of Business Managers: a Definition and Research Model,
  65. (1974). Innovation Business Innovator • Responsible for progress of project
  66. (1989). It Takes A Champion,
  67. Leaders and champions 1997 USA Innovation Construction Qualitative Champions need resources and power to innovate in construction. Page 162 of 214 for construction innovation, doi
  68. (1970). Leadership Without Formal Authority: The Project Department, doi
  69. (1999). Leading the development and implementation of collaborative interorganizational systems, doi
  70. (1997). Learning and Awareness, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,
  71. (1990). Learning and instruction: European research in an international context., Vol. 2.1: Social and cognitive aspects of learning and instruction, doi
  72. (1991). Learning the Ropes: My Life as a Product Champion, Harvard Business Review,
  73. Maintaining Professional Competence: Approaches to Career Enhancement, Vitality and Success Through A Work Life, Jossey Bass () N/K USA Competence Practitioner Competence is necessary for high levels of productivity, but by itself it is not sufficient.
  74. (1988). Management competence in the public sector., doi
  75. Management of Capabilities and Situations in R&D Centres: The Matrix of Competences., doi
  76. (1988). Management training: acts of faith, scenes of competence.,
  77. Managerial Competence and The Charter Initiative,
  78. (1995). Managerial Competencies: doi
  79. Managerial Resourcefulness: A Reconceptualization of Management Skills, Human Relations, Volume 45, doi
  80. (1993). Meta-competence: A recipe for reframing the competence debate, Personnel Review, doi
  81. Models: An Expansion?, doi
  82. Moving technologies from lab to market,
  83. (1999). N/A Phenomenography Nature of phenomenography Theoretical Phenomenography relies on conceptions (what and Page 187 of 214 Phenomenography: a Qualitative Research Approach for Exploring Understanding in Health Care, doi
  84. (2000). N/R Competence Theoretical Posits the idea that public sector managers have 3 distinctive competencies: interpretive, institutional and textual. There is conflict between these and this generates ambiguity.
  85. (1996). nd Edition, doi
  86. (2002). Office of Government Commerce, Managing Successful Projects with PRINCE2, 3 rd Edition
  87. Old Public Administration to New Public Management, Public Money and Management, doi
  88. (2003). On the nature of the project as a temporary organization, doi
  89. (1991). Organizational Learning and Communities-Of-Practice: Towards a Unified View of Working, Learning and Innovation, doi
  90. (1992). Organizing and Leading 'Heavyweight' Development Teams doi
  91. (1992). Organizing and Leading 'Heavyweight' Development Teams, doi
  92. (1986). Phenomenography -A Research Approach to 1986 N/R Phenomenography Theoretical Phenomenography deals with the relationship Page 195 of 214 Investigating Different Understandings of Reality,
  93. (1977). Power and Innovation: A Two Centre Theory, International
  94. (1998). Problems of Ethics in doi
  95. (2001). Product champion characteristics in doi
  96. (2001). Product champions: Truths, myths and management, Research Technology
  97. (1987). Product Development in the World Auto Industry, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, doi
  98. (1995). Project Management: A Systems Approach to Planning, Scheduling and Controlling, 5 th Edition,
  99. (1983). Public Management Trends: Managerial Accountability and Responsibility,
  100. (2002). Public Sector Innovation and Entrepreneurship: Case Studies from Local Government, Local Government Studies, Vol.28, Part 4, Winter, doi
  101. (1997). Reconstructing Public Management a New Responsibility for the Public and a Case Study of Local Government., doi
  102. Requirements for Successful Reengineering, INFOR,
  103. (1993). Rescuing the useful concept of managerial competence: From outcomes back to process, doi
  104. (2001). Resource Management: A Critical Text, Thomson Learning
  105. (1988). Riding The Waves of Change: Developing Managerial Competencies for a Turbulent World, Jossey-Bass Inc., doi
  106. (1974). SAPPHO Updated -Project SAPPHO Phase II, Research policy, doi
  107. Search for Excellence Within a Systems Development Project,
  108. (1982). Search of Excellence doi
  109. (1998). Stakeholders views of management development as a cultural change process in the health service., doi
  110. (2002). study: Factors for early prediction of software development success, doi
  111. (1989). Suggestions for Managing The Innovation Journey
  112. (1989). Suggestions for Managing The Innovation Journey, in
  113. (1994). The accountant's contribution to executive information systems,
  114. (1995). The Chameleon of Accountability: Forms and Discourses, Accounting, Organizations and Society, doi
  115. (1983). The Change 1983 USA Entrepreneurship Management Practitioner Change will not be implemented Page
  116. (1993). The competence movement: Issues, stakeholders and prospects, Personnel Review, Vol.22, Part 6, doi
  117. (1996). The Competencies of New Public Managers, in Farnham, D.//Horton, S.//Barlow, J.//Hondehagem, A., New Public Managers in Europe: Public Servants in Transition,
  118. (1982). The Competent Manager: A Model for Effective Performance, doi
  119. (2001). The competent primary head teacher: broadening the management competence approach or abandoning it?, doi
  120. (1999). The Concepts doi
  121. (1994). The consultant's role in re1994 USA BPR Management Consulting Practitioner Sponsorship needs to be sustained. Differentiates between sponsor,
  122. (1995). The Effects of Cultural Differences on New Technology Championing Behaviour Within Firms, doi
  123. (1994). The Hollowing Out of The State: The Changing Nature of the Public Sector in Britain, Political Quarterly, Autumn, doi
  124. The Management Information and Decision Support System (MIDS) at Lockheed-Georgia, doi
  125. (1996). The Management Of Complex Tasks In Organizations: Controlling The Systems doi
  126. (1994). The most fatal reengineering mistakes,
  127. (1998). The New Public Management Paradigm and the Search for Democratic Accountability, doi
  128. (1999). The Paradox of Managerialism, Public Administration Review, doi
  129. (1996). The PDMA Handbook of New Product Development, doi
  130. The Policy Implementation Process, Administration and Society, doi
  131. (1987). The Post-It Note: An Intrapreneurial Success,
  132. The Processes of Public Accountability, doi
  133. (1989). The Project Champion: Key to Implementation Success, doi
  134. (2002). The project manager and the project2002 UK Project Management General Qualitative Project sponsors are powerful and can be mobilised by the project Page 148 of 214 network,
  135. (1990). The Quest for Competence, Industrial and Commercial Training, doi
  136. (2001). The role and importance of development directors in initiating and implementing development strategy, doi
  137. (1990). The Role and Weaknesses of Top Management in Internal Projects,
  138. (1974). The Role of Champion in Product Innovation,
  139. (1998). The Role of Tacit Knowledge in Group Innovation, California Management Review, Volume 40, Part 3, Spring, doi
  140. (1999). The Roles Of R&D Team Leaders In Korea: A Contingent Approach., doi
  141. (1988). The Roles of User and Sponsor in MIS Projects
  142. The Shape of Ideology: Structure, Culture and Policy Delivery in the New Public Sector, doi
  143. (1992). The State of The Art of Entrepreneurship, PWS Kent,
  144. (1995). The Two Faces Of Championship: An Examination Of The Behavioural And Individual-Differences Characteristics Of The Champion, PhD Thesis,
  145. (2000). Total quality, public doi
  146. (1996). Twelve Reasons Why Programs Fail,
  147. types of champion: bottom up, top down and dual-role. There is also the organizational sponsor (undefined).
  148. (1991). UK Change Management UK Public Sector / Central Government reform Qualitative FMI was primarily aimed at operational areas and cost accountability. Changed civil service perceptions of accountability. Missed the larger spending departments.
  149. (1995). UK Civil Service Accountability Central Government Theoretical Civil service accountability remains unclear with the recent NPM changes. There are conflicts between the NPM changes and traditional forms of accountability that are as yet unresolved. doi
  150. (2002). UK Intranet IS Practitioner Sponsors track usage, select content managers and line training.
  151. (2002). UK Project Sponsorship Public Sector Qualitative Project sponsors in the public sector are caught between the realities of the public service ethos and the financially driven private sector.
  152. (2001). Understanding Competence at Work., Harvard Business Review,
  153. (2000). Understanding Human Competence At Work: An Interpretative Approach, doi
  154. Upward Influence Styles of R&D Project Leaders, doi
  155. USA Budgeting Corporate Planning Practitioner Sponsor needed for budget planning – needs political power.
  156. (1993). USA Competence Work Competence Quantitative Competency is an underlying characteristic of an individual that is Page
  157. (1981). USA HR Management Innovation Theoretical Needed roles in innovation are the champion and the sponsor.
  158. (1979). USA Innovation Innovation Theoretical Individual entrepreneurship is more difficult in organizations due to institutional nature. Innovation is required for organization to survive. Champions are required for organizational innovations.
  159. USA MIS IT Implementation Theoretical Sponsor promotes and spearheads the development of the system, does not have daily responsibility for the management of the project.
  160. (1998). USA Project Leadership Project Management Practitioner Championing and sponsoring as key roles in project delivery. Role Page
  161. (1994). USA Reengineering IT Theoretical Champions should be bearers of persuasive and evaluative information about an innovation.
  162. (2000). Ways of learning about leisure meanings, doi
  163. Ways to Waste an EIS Investment,
  164. (1992). What is meant by a competency?, in Boam, R.//Sparrow, P., Designing and Achieving Competency,
  165. (1988). What We've Learned: Managing Human Resources,
  166. (1988). When a Thousand Flowers Bloom: Structural, Collective and Social Conditions For Innovation In Organizations, doi
  167. Why Reengineering Projects Fail,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.