Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

The effectiveness of marketing strategy making processes in medical markets

By Brian D. Smith


This thesis contributes to the understanding of the effectiveness of marketing strategy making processes. It examines how such effectiveness is contingent upon the internal and external environments in which the process operates and, therefore, how the requisite process is contingent upon its organisational and market context. It builds on the fields of strategy content and strategy process and of organisational effectiveness, organisational culture and organisation theory. It tests and develops Burrell and Morgan’s congruency hypotheses as an explanation of the effectiveness of marketing strategy making processes. That work postulates that effectiveness results when the process is congruent with both its internal environment (i.e. microcongruent) and external environment (i.e. macrocongruent) This work takes a pragmatist epistemological perspective. The methodology is qualitative, using multiple-informant case studies. The congruency hypotheses are operationalised using a model and constructs based on the extant literature. The work is restricted to the medical products market in order to optimise insight and understanding. The findings support the congruency hypotheses. Strong strategy is associated with simultaneous macrocongruence and microcongruence. Further, a mechanism for the hypotheses is identified. Interactions between the strategy process and organisational structure, systems and habits provide an underlying mechanism of microcongruence. Failure or success of the process to manage market complexity and turbulence provide an underlying mechanism of macrocongruence. This work contributes to theory, confirming the congruency hypotheses, extending them into marketing strategy making and making a new contribution concerning the mechanism of congruency. To methodology, this work confirms the use of case studies, extends it to consider simultaneously internal and external environments and makes a new contribution concerning the construct of strategy quality. To practice, the work confirms the value of planning in complex markets, extends the concept of a “requisite” process and contributes new ideas for the deliberate management of marketing strategy making processes

Publisher: School of Management
Year: 2003
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (1993). Marketing Planning: An Empirical Analysis of Practices in British Companies.
  2. (1979). Organisations and Environments, Prentice-Hall,
  3. (1970). Trappings Versus Substance in Industrial Marketing",
  4. (1982). Marketing, Strategic Planning, and the Theory of the Firm", doi
  5. (1987). The Concept of Corporate Strategy, 3rd edn, doi
  6. (1991). Critique of Henry Mintzberg's "The Design School: Reconsidering the Basic Premises of Strategic Management"", doi
  7. (1996). Diagnosing Organizational Planning Benefits: The Efficacy of Planning Formalization", doi
  8. (1980). Practical Corporate Planning, George Allen and Unwin,
  9. (1982). The Value of Formal Planning for Strategic Decisions: Review of Empirical Research", doi
  10. (1994). A Framework for Understanding Strategy Development. Ref Type: Unpublished Work The Effectiveness of Marketing Strategy Making Processes in Medical Markets
  11. (1971). The Faltering Marketing Concept", doi
  12. (1985). Leaders: The Strategies for Taking Charge, doi
  13. (1983). Dysfunctional Effects of Formal Planning: Two Theoretical Explanations", doi
  14. (1993). Approaches to Social Enquiry, doi
  15. (1985). Case Research in Marketing: Opportunities, Problems and a Process", doi
  16. (1985). The Marketing Edge: Making Strategies Work, 1st edn, doi
  17. (1995). Strategic networks among small firms: implications for strategy research methodology", doi
  18. (1984). Strategic Implementation: Five Approaches to an Elusive Phenomenon", doi
  19. (1997). Using Single Respondents in Strategy Research", doi
  20. (1986). Planning and Financial Performance in doi
  21. (1979). Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis, 1st edn, Sage, doi
  22. (2003). The Effectiveness of Marketing Strategy Making Processes in Medical Markets
  23. (1986). Effectiveness as a Paradox: Consensus and Conflict in Conceptions of Organisational Effectiveness", doi
  24. (1989). Marketing Planning in Small Enterprises: A Model and Some Empirical Evidence", doi
  25. (1998). Using Computer Software for the Analysis of Qualitative Market Research Data", doi
  26. (1996). Implementing Marketing Strategy", doi
  27. (1985). Three Models of Strategy", doi
  28. (1986). Measuring Strategic Performance", doi
  29. (1992). Strategy Process Research: Focusing on Corporate Self-Renewal", doi
  30. (1992). Notes on Pragmatism and Scientific Realism", doi
  31. (2000). The Effects of Formal Strategic Marketing Planning on the Industrial Firm's Configuration, Structure, Exchange Patterns and Performance", doi
  32. (1979). Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings, 1st edn,
  33. (1998). Qualitative Enquiry and Research Design: Choosing among Five Traditions,
  34. (1963). A Behavioural Theory of the Firm, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, doi
  35. (1982). Corporate Cultures: The Rites and Rituals of Corporate Life, 1st edn, doi
  36. (1999). To Be Different, Or To Be The Same? It's A Question (and Theory) of Strategic Balance", doi
  37. (1984). Bringing Corporate Culture to the Bottom Line", doi
  38. (1990). Corporate Culture and Organizational Effectiveness, 1st edn,
  39. (1996). What is the Difference Between Organizational Culture and Organizational Climate? A Native's Point of View on a Decade of Paradigm Wars", doi
  40. (1995). Towards a Theory of Organisational Culture and Effectiveness",
  41. (1989). Organizational Culture and Marketing: Defining the Research Agenda", doi
  42. (1983). The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organisational Field", doi
  43. (2000). Implementing Marketing Strategy Through a Market Orientation", doi
  44. (1993). Corporate Culture: Use It, Don't Lose It,"
  45. (1993). The Governance of Corporations,"
  46. (1994). The Impact of Organisational Values, Goals and Climate on Marketing Effectiveness", doi
  47. (2003). Revisiting the Logical and Research Considerations of Competitive Advantage", doi
  48. (1995). Management Research: An Introduction,
  49. (1970). The CEO's Role in Corporate Growth",
  50. (2002). Marketing: A Critical Realist Approach", doi
  51. (1989). Building Theories from Case Study Research", doi
  52. (1989). Making Fast Strategic Decisions in HighVelocity Environments", doi
  53. (1999). Strategy as Strategic Decision Making", doi
  54. (1992). Strategic Decision Making", doi
  55. (1998). Computer Analysis and Qualitative Research Sage, doi
  56. (1988). Can Change in Organisational Culture Really Be Managed", doi
  57. (1993). Constructive Questions for Interviews and Questionnaires: Theory and Practice in Social Research, doi
  58. (1984). The Comprehensiveness of Strategic Decision Processes: Extension, Observations, Future Directions", doi
  59. (1984). Strategic Decision Processes; Comprehensiveness and Performance in an Industry with an Unstable Environment", doi
  60. (1999). Strategic Planning: Still Going Strong", doi
  61. (2000). Taking Stock of Synergy: A Framework for Assessing Linkages Between Businesses",
  62. (1984). An Understanding of Marketing Strategy", doi
  63. (1985). Marketing Plan Utilisation",
  64. (1995). Market Orientation and Company Performance: Empirical Evidence from UK Companies", doi
  65. (1994). Marketing Planning Processes in UK and US Companies", doi
  66. (1997). Multiple Stakeholder Orientation in UK Companies and the Implications for Company Performance", doi
  67. (1994). Competing Paradigms in Qualitative Research,"
  68. (1983). An Empirical Typology of Mature IndustrialProduct Environments", doi
  69. (1984). Structural Inertia and Organisational Change", doi
  70. (1983). Research Methodologies for Contingency Approaches to Business Strategy", doi
  71. (1996). The Anti-Planner's Tactics to Thwart Planning Initiation", doi
  72. (1999). Initiating Planning: The Problem of Entrenched Cultural Values",
  73. (1999). Management Behavior and Barriers to Market Orientation in Retailing Companies", doi
  74. (2000). Getting Professionals to Plan: Pressures, Obstacles and Tactical Responses", doi
  75. (1999). Developing a Market Oriented Culture: A Critical Evaluation", doi
  76. (1999). The Strategic Legacy of Company Founders", doi
  77. (2001). Strategic human resource management, market orientation, and organizational performance", doi
  78. (2002). The Unintended Consequences of Culture Interventions: A Study of Unexpected Outcomes", doi
  79. (1991). Intentionality and Autonomy in the Strategy Making Process: Modes, Archetypes and Firm Process",
  80. (1992). An Integrative Framework for Strategy Making Processes", doi
  81. (1982). Portfolio Planning: Uses and Limits",
  82. (2003). The Cultural Dynamics of Organisational Change,"
  83. (2000). Strategic Decision Making, Discourse and Strategy as Social Practice", doi
  84. (2003). The Struture and Significance of Strategic Episodes: Social Systems Theory and the Routine Practices of Strategic Change", doi
  85. (1995). The Impact of Marketing Signals on Strategic Decision -Making Ability and Profitability", doi
  86. (1972). Long Range Planning and Organisational Performance: A Cross Validation Study", doi
  87. (1986). Top Decisions: Strategic Decision Making in Organisations, JosseyBass, doi
  88. (1987). A Pragmatic Methodology for Social Economics: A Preliminary Proposal", doi
  89. (2001). TheoryTesting Using Case Studies: doi
  90. (1974). Structural Conditions of Intraorganizational Power", doi
  91. (1986). Humanistic Enquiry in Marketing Research: Philosophy, Method and Criteria", doi
  92. (1986). Strategy Formulation: Analytical Concepts, 11th edn,
  93. (1984). Cultural Dimensions in Management and Planning", Asia Pacific doi
  94. (1990). Marketing in the UK: A Survey of Current Practice and Performance, 1st edn, Institute of Marketing,
  95. (1981). The Marketing Plan The Conference Board,
  96. (1991). Realism in Research", doi
  97. (1988). Against the Quantitative- Qualitative Incompatibilty Thesis or Dgomas Die Hard",
  98. (1991). Modern Marketing Theory, doi
  99. (1991). Positivism and Paradigm Dominance in Consumer Research: Towards Critical Pluralism and Rapprochement", doi
  100. (1988). Tracing Emergent Processes in Marketing Strategy Formation", doi
  101. (1925). Pragmatism: A New Way for Old Thinking, 1st edn,
  102. (1997). Market Segmentation: Organisational Archetypes and Research Agenda", doi
  103. (1988). Rethinking Incrementalism", doi
  104. (1999). Theory Testing Using Case Studies in Business-to-Business Research", doi
  105. (1992). The Balanced Scorecard -Measures that Drive Performance",
  106. (1975). Long Range Planning and Organizational Performance", Long Range Planning, doi
  107. (1988). A Causal Model of Linkages Among Environmental Dimensions, Macro Organizational Characteristics and Performance", doi
  108. (1990). Market Orientation: the Construct, Research Propositions and Managerial Implications", doi
  109. (1990). A Force for Change: How Leadership Differs from Management, doi
  110. (2001). Realism and Constructivism in Strategy Research: A Critical Realist Response to Mir and Watson", doi
  111. (1998). An Empirical Investigation into the Process of Strategic Marketing Planning in SMEs: Its Attendant Problems, and Proposals Towards a New Practical Paradigm", doi
  112. (1967). Differentiation and Integration in Complex Organisations", doi
  113. (1982). Problems of Reliabilty and Validity in Ethnographic Research", doi
  114. (1994). Managing Culture: Fact or Fiction,"
  115. (1986). Determining Organizational Effectiveness: Another Look, and an Agenda for Research", doi
  116. (1959). The Science of Muddling Through", doi
  117. (1980). Impact of the Organization Environment on the Long Range Planning Process: A Contingency View", doi
  118. (1995). Market Orientation and Firm Size: An Empirical Examination in UK Firms", doi
  119. (1986). Managing Culture: The Invisible Barrier to Strategic Change", doi
  120. (1997). Corporate Strategy, 1st edn,
  121. (1997). Strategy Evaluation and Selection,"
  122. (1992). Strategic marketing planning, environmental uncertainty and performance", doi
  123. (2003). Orchestral Manoeuvres in the Dark: Understanding Failure in Organisational Strategizing", doi
  124. (2002). Management Control Systems and their Effects on Strategy Formation at Middle-Management Levels: Evidence from a UK Organisation", doi
  125. (1979). Business Planning: The Gap Between Theory and Practice", doi
  126. (1987). Marketing Planning and the Human Element",
  127. (1992). Cultures in Organizations: Three Perspectives, 1st edn,
  128. (1999). Designing Experiments and Analyzing Data: A Model Comparison Perspective, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,
  129. (1982). Theory and practice of marketing planning for industrial goods in international markets,
  130. (1985). Methodological Problems Associated with Qualitative Research: Some Observations and a Case Analysis in International Marketing Planning",
  131. (1989). Ten Barriers to Marketing Planning", doi
  132. (1996). Strategic Marketing Planning: Theory, Practice, doi
  133. (1999). Exploiting Technique Interrelationships: A Model of Strategic Marketing Planning", doi
  134. (1994). Strategic Planning and Financial Performance in UK SMEs", doi
  135. (1972). The Present Status of the Marketing Concept", doi
  136. (1999). Antecedants and Consequences of Marketing Strategy Making: A Model and a Test", doi
  137. (1996). The Quality and Effectiveness of Marketing Strategy: Effects of Functional and Dysfunctional Conflict in Intraorganisational Relationships", doi
  138. (1994). Qualitative Data Analysis, 2nd edn, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks:CA. doi
  139. (1978). Patterns of Strategy Formation", doi
  140. (1990). The Design School: Reconsidering The Basic Premises of Strategic Management", doi
  141. (2000). View from the Top: Henry Mintzberg on Strategy and Management", doi
  142. (1976). The Structure of Unstructured Decision Making Processes", doi
  143. (2000). Strategic Management and the Philosophy of Science: The Case for a Constructivist Methodology.", doi
  144. (2001). Criticism Realism and Constructivism in Strategy Research: Towards a Synthesis", doi
  145. (1986). Images of Organization, doi
  146. (1985). The Content Analysis of Qualitative Research Data: A Dynamic Approach,"
  147. (1992). The Evaluation Stage in Marketing Decision Making", doi
  148. (2003). A Congruence Model for Organizational Assessment,"
  149. (1999). The Performance Measurement Revolution: Why Now and What Next", doi
  150. (1995). Performance Measurement System and Design", doi
  151. (1993). Managing Organisational Culture: Fantasy or Reality?", doi
  152. (1987). The Epistemology of Action Research", doi
  153. (1991). Studying information technology in organisations: research approaches and assumptions", doi
  154. (1993). Messy Research, Methodogical Predispositions and Theory Development in International Joint Ventures", doi
  155. (1987). The Tenuous Link Between Formal Planning and Financial Performance", doi
  156. (1980). Improving Strategy Formulation Pedagogies By Recognizing Behavioral Aspects", doi
  157. (1987). The Impact of Grand Strategy and Planning Formality on Financial Performance", doi
  158. (2003). The Effectiveness of Marketing Strategy Making Processes in Medical Markets (2003) Page 269 The Effectiveness of Marketing Strategy Making doi
  159. (1999). Influence of Environment, Strategy and Market Orientation on Performance in Small Manufacturing Firms", doi
  160. (1996). A Longitudinal Study of the Impact of Market Structure, Firm Structure, Strategy, and Market Orientation Culture on Dimensions of Small Firm Performance", doi
  161. (1997). Qualitative Methods in Entrepreneurship Research",
  162. (1998). Realism Rules OK: Scientific Paradigms in Marketing Research About Networks",
  163. (1973). The Politics of Organisational Decision Making, doi
  164. (1979). On Studying Organizational Cultures", doi
  165. (1987). Context and action in the transformation of the firm", doi
  166. (1997). Market-Led Strategic Change: Transforming the Process of Going to Market, 2nd edn,
  167. (1989). Making SWOT Analysis Work", doi
  168. (1996). Market Orientation and Business Performance: Some European Evidence", doi
  169. (1996). What is Strategy?",
  170. (1995). Rationality in Strategic Decision Processes, Environmental Dynamism and Firm Performance", doi
  171. (1996). Planning and Doing: The Relationship Between Marketing Planning Styles and Market Orientation", doi
  172. (1980). Strategies for Change: Logical Incrementalism, doi
  173. (1993). Strategic Decision Processes: Critical Review and Future Directions", doi
  174. (1989). Strategic Planning: The Cultural Impact",
  175. (1986). The Relationship of Strategic Planning to Financial Performance", doi
  176. (1993). Real World Research: A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner Researchers, doi
  177. (1987). Developing the Strategic Plan", doi
  178. (1989). Strategic Management: A Methodological Approach, Third edn,
  179. (1973). Is Long Range Planning Profitable?", Academy of Management Proceedings, doi
  180. (1987). Marketing's Interaction with Other Functional Units: A Conceptual Approach and Empirical Evidence", doi
  181. (1997). The Evaluation of Business Strategy,"
  182. (1992). Corporate Culture: Is it Really a Barrier to Marketing Planning", doi
  183. (1992). Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach, 2nd edn, doi
  184. (1984). Coming to a New Awareness of Organisational Culture",
  185. (1991). What is Culture?," in Reframing Organizational Culture, First
  186. (1981). Matching Corporate Culture and Business Strategy", doi
  187. (1993). Effects of Formal Strategic Planning on Financial Performance in Small Firms: A MetaAnalysis", Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,
  188. (1975). Long Range Strategic Planning and Its Relationship to Firm Size, Firm Growth and Firm Variability: An Explorative Empirical Exploration, PhD Thesis,
  189. (1984). Strategic Planning and Organisational Planning: A Critical Appraisal",
  190. (1985). Empirically Derived Models of Strategic Decision Making", doi
  191. (2000). The Positive Effect of Market Orientation on Business Profitability: A Balanced Replication", doi
  192. (1997). Strategy Formation Patterns, Performance and the Significance of Context", doi
  193. (1983). Concepts of Culture and Organizational Analysis",
  194. (1999). Strategic Marketing Planning in doi
  195. (1994). Environmental Context and Marketing Planning Processes",
  196. (1981). Case Studies,"
  197. (1983). Structural Analysis and the Marketing Concept: Problems and Solutions,"
  198. (1999). Marketing Orientation and the Marketing Strategy Process",
  199. (1968). Organizational Climate: Explorations of a Concept, doi
  200. (1970). Where Long Range Planning Pays Off: Findings of a Survey of Formal, Informal Planners", doi
  201. (1999). Replication and Theory Development in Organisational Science: A Critical Realist Perspective", doi
  202. (1989). The Validity of Idiographic Research Explanations", doi
  203. (2002). Informants in Organisational Marketing Research: Why Use Multiple Respondents and How to Aggregate Responses", doi
  204. (1999). Strategy Content and Process Perspectives Revisited", doi
  205. (1988). Marketing Planning for Improved Performance: A Comparitive Analysis", doi
  206. (1987). Marketing's Role in the Implementation of Business Strategies: A Critical Review and Conceptual Framework", doi
  207. (1985). The Significance of Organisational Culture," in Organisational Culture, doi
  208. (1989). Visionary Leadership and Strategic Management", doi
  209. (1998). Organisation Studies and the New Pragmatism: Positivism, Anti-Positivism and the Search for Ethics", doi
  210. (1983). Efficient Cultures: Exploring the Relationship between Culture and Organisational Performance", doi
  211. (1989). Commercial Use of Conjoint Analysis: An Update”, doi
  212. (1989). The Barriers to Achieving a Stronger Market Orientation in British Companies: An Exploratory Study",
  213. (1979). The Impact of Comprehensive Planning on Financial Performance", doi
  214. (1989). Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 1st edn, Sage Publications,
  215. (1985). Problems and Strategies in Service Marketing", doi
  216. (1988). The Contingency Approach: Its Foundations and Relevance to Theory Building and Research in Marketing", doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.