Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Fatigue crack growth rates under variable amplitude load spectra containing tensile underloads

By Vasilios Zitounis


An extensive research program was performed to investigate the load interaction effect of the combined action of small amplitude high R ratio cycles and large amplitude low R ratio underloads on the crack growth of large cracks. The study was driven by the needs of the damage tolerance approach in the helicopter structures, which requires robust knowledge on the crack growth behaviour of the advance high strength alloys under the characteristic helicopter spectra loading. The study was conducted on three metallic alloys, Ti-10V-2Fe-3Al, Al8090 T852 and Al7010 T76351 using compact tension specimens (w=70mm, t=17mm). The potential drop technique was used for the measurements of the crack length. The crack opening loads were determined from the applied load versus crack opening mouth displacement curve using a curve fitting technique and crack opening displacement gauge. The experimental results show that cracks can grow faster than the life predictions with no load interaction effects under spectra containing tensile underloads. The acceleration effects are different depending on the number of the small cycles, the Kmax, the R ratio of the small cycles, the underload cycle and the material. Significant closure observations on the underloads and on the small cycles of variable amplitude loading spectra were made. Based on the test finding and on the studies of other researchers, it is suggested that the acceleration effects are mainly due to the reduction of crack opening point of the tensile underloads comparing with the Constant Amplitude Loading (CAL) data. An extensive evaluation of the ability of FASTRAN model to predict the fatigue lives under the tested loading spectra was carried out. The evaluation focuses on the influence of the constraint factor a and the ∆Keff curve inputs on the predictions. The model produces very good and consistent predictions for the three alloys, when the inputs represent adequately the actual fatigue mechanism. The model predicts the measured acceleration effects by reducing the closure level of the underloads

Topics: Crack growth, Constant amplitude loading, FASTRAN, Fatigue
Publisher: School of Industrial and Manufacturing Science
Year: 2003
OAI identifier:
Provided by: Cranfield CERES

Suggested articles


  1. (1990). A Comparison of Fatigue Life Prediction Methodologies for Rotorcraft’, doi
  2. A crack closure model for predicting fatigue crack growth under aircraft spectrum loading’, Methods and models model for predicting fatigue crack growth under random loading, doi
  3. (1971). A crack growth retardation madel using an effective stress concept’, AFFDL-TR-71-1, Air Force Fligth Dynamics Laboratory, Wrigth-Patterson Air Force Base,
  4. (1971). A crack growth retardation model using an effective stress concept’, AFFDL-TR-71-1, Air Force Flight Dynamics Laboratory, Wright-Patterson Air Force Base,
  5. (1984). A crack opening stress equation for fatigue crack growth’. doi
  6. (2001). A discrete dislocation analysis of near-threshold fatigue crack growth’, doi
  7. (1998). A Dislocation Barrier Model For Fatigue Crack Growth Threshold’, doi
  8. (1996). A dislocation model for the two critical stress intensities required for the threshold fatigue crack propagation’, doi
  9. (1996). A Dislocation Model For The Two Critical Stress Intensities Required For Threshold Fatigue Crack Propagation’, doi
  10. (1989). A new model for fatigue crack growth retardation following an overload’, doi
  11. (1999). A numerical investigation on the effect of an overload on fatigue crack opening and closure behaviour’, doi
  12. (1961). A rational analytic theory of fatigue’,
  13. (1994). A review of crack closure, fatigue crack threshold and related phenomena’, doi
  14. (1981). A simple crack closure model for prediction of fatigue crack growth rates under variable amplitude loading’, doi
  15. A Study Of Crack Closure Using The Optical Method Of Caustics And Consequences For The Use Of ∆keff As A Fatigue Crack Driving Force’, doi
  16. A.K ‘A theoretical evaluation of crack closure’, doi
  17. (1994). Acceleration Of Fatigue Crack Growth Under Intermittent Overstressing With Different Mean Stress Levels’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  18. (2000). AFGROW Users manual, Version 4.0001.11.8,
  19. (1996). An Analytical Model for Fatigue Life Prediction Based on Fracture Mechanics and Crack Closure’, doi
  20. (1996). An analytical model for fatigue life predictions based on fracture mechanics and crack closure’, doi
  21. (1998). An argument for cycle-by-cycle propagation of fatigue cracks at small stress intensity ranges’, doi
  22. (1981). An assessment of A-C and D-C potential systems for monitoring fatigue crack growth’, fatigue Crack Growth Measurement and Data Analysis. doi
  23. (1993). An assessment of fatigue crack growth prediction models for aerospace structures’,
  24. An elastic-plastic analytical model for predicting fatigue crack growth in arbitrary edge-cracked twodimensional geometries with residual stress’, doi
  25. An Engineering Model for Assessing Load Sequencing Effects’, Ef f e c t o f l o a d S p e c t r u m V a r i a b l e o n fatigue Crack Initiation and Propagation, doi
  26. (1999). An evaluation of ∆Keff estimation procedures on 6061-T6 and 2024-T3 aluminium alloys’, doi
  27. (1995). An evaluation of fatigue crack growth prediction methods used in aircraft design’,
  28. (1999). An Evaluation Of Plasticity-Induced Crack Closure Concept And Measurements Method’, doi
  29. (1984). An Investigation Of Fatigue Crack Closure’, doi
  30. (1978). Analysis of closure in fatigue crack growth’, doi
  31. (1986). Analysis Of Crack Closure Under Plane Strain Conditions’, doi
  32. (1999). Analysis Of Overload Effects And Related Phenomena’, doi
  33. Analysis of stress and strain near the end of a crack traversing a plate’,
  34. (1980). Application of Damage Tolerance Concepts for MBB Helicopters’,
  35. ASTM standards E647, Standard Test Method for Measurement of Fatigue Crack Growth Rates. American Society for Testing and Materials doi
  36. (1939). Bearing pressures and cracks’,
  37. (2001). Behavior of Plasticity-Induced Crack Closure and Roughness-Induced Crack Closure in Aluminum Alloy’, doi
  38. (2002). Certain Aspects of Variable Amplitude Fatigue’, doi
  39. (1995). Changes in crack opening stress after underloads and overloads in 2024-T351 aluminium alloy’, doi
  40. Circular, AC 29.571-1, Fatigue Evaluation of Transport Category Rotorcraft Structure, Federal Aviation Administration,
  41. (1995). Classification of fatigue crack growth behavior’, doi
  42. (1999). Comparison of Contemporary FCG Life Prediction Tools’, doi
  43. (1976). Compendium Of Stress Intensity Factors’, Her Majesty’s Stationary Office,
  44. (1992). Contribution of Individual Load Cycles to Crack Growth Under Air craft Spectrum Loading ’, doi
  45. (1997). Crack Closure: A Concept of Fatigue Crack Growth Under Examination’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  46. (1993). Crack Growth Predictions Using a Crack Closure Model’, doi
  47. (2001). Critical Parameters For Fatigue Damage’, doi
  48. (1954). Cumulative Damage in Fatigue’, doi
  49. (1977). Current status of flight simulation fatigue crack growth concepts’,
  50. (1975). Cyclic analysis of a propagating crack and its correlation with fatigue crack growth’, doi
  51. (1991). Damage Tolerance Analysis for Rotorcraft: What the issues are,’ 17 th European Rotorcraft Forum,
  52. (1998). Damage tolerance applied to metallic components’, th European Rotorcraft Forum,
  53. (1998). Description Of Load Interaction Effects By The ∆Keff-Concept’,
  54. Dislocation behavior under fatigue’
  55. (1994). Effects of compressive load excursion on fatigue crack growth’, doi
  56. (1996). Effects of Delamination on fatigue crack growth retardation after single tensile overload doi
  57. (1980). Effects of Fligther Attach Spectrum on Crack Growth’, Effect of load Spectrum Variable on fatigue doi
  58. (1980). Effects of Gas Turbine Engines Load Spectrum Variables on Crack doi
  59. (1980). Effects of Gust Load Alleviation on Fatigue Crack Growth doi
  60. Effects of Kmax on Fatigue crack growth threshold in aluminium alloys’, doi
  61. (2001). Effects of load ratio and maximum stress intensity on the fatigue threshold in doi
  62. (1980). Effects of Transport Aircraft Wing Loads Spectrum Variation on Fatigue Crack Growth Rates’, Effect of load Spectrum Variable on fatigue doi
  63. (1975). Elastic plastic analysis of a propagating crack under cyclic loading’, doi
  64. (2000). Enhanced Model of The Partial Crack Closure For Correlation Of R-Ratio Effects In Aluminium Alloys’, doi
  65. (1980). Evaluating Spectrum Effects in U.S. Air Force Attack/Figther/Trainer Individual Aircraft Tracking’, Effect of load Spectrum doi
  66. (1993). Exact Determination Of ∆keff And Crack Propagation Prediction For Selected Loading Sequences’, In:
  67. Extensive study of low fatigue crack rates doi
  68. (1992). FASTRAN II – A Fatigue Crack Growth Structural Analysis Program’,
  69. Fatigue crack closure and growth behaviour under random loading’, doi
  70. (1996). Fatigue Crack Closure As A Function of Crack Length doi
  71. (1995). Fatigue Crack Closure Measurements On 2024-T3 Sheet Specimens’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  72. Fatigue Crack Closure Study Based On Whole-Field Displacements’, doi
  73. (1986). Fatigue Crack Closure, Observations And doi
  74. (1995). Fatigue Crack Growth And Closure At High Stress Ratios’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  75. (1985). Fatigue crack growth due to periodic underloads and overloads’ doi
  76. Fatigue crack growth from simulated fligth cycles involving superimposed vibrations’, doi
  77. (1999). Fatigue crack growth in a structural steel under single and multiple periodic overload cycles’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  78. (1996). Fatigue crack growth under the conjoint action of major and minor stress cycles’, doi
  79. (2002). Fatigue Crack Propagation In
  80. (1962). Fatigue crack propagation in light alloy sheet material and structures’, doi
  81. (1995). Fatigue crack propagation mechanism in an aluminium lithium alloy’, doi
  82. (1996). Fatigue of cast aluminium alloys under constant and variable- amplitude loading’, doi
  83. (1998). Fatigue of Materials’, doi
  84. (2001). Fatigue of Structures and Materials’, doi
  85. (2001). Fatigue threshold and crack propagation in TiAl sheets’, doi
  86. (1986). Finite Element Analysis Of Plasticity-Induced Crack Closure Under Plane Strain Conditions’, doi
  87. (1979). Flight simulation fatigue crack propagation evaluation of candidate lower wind skin materials with particular consideration of spectrum truncation’,
  88. (1980). Helicopter Component Fatigue Life Determination’, Helicopter Fatigue Life Assessment, doi
  89. (1978). Helicopter Fatigue Evaluation’, Helicopter Fatigue-A review of current requirements and substantiation procedures,
  90. (1997). Introducing The Compliance Ratio Concept For Determining Effective Stress Intensity’, doi
  91. (1998). Introducing the Kmax sensitivity Concept For Correlating Fatigue Crack Propagation’, High Cycle Fatigue Of Structural Materials:
  92. (1999). Investigation of helicopter loading spectra variations on fatigue growth in Titanium and Aluminium Alloys’, Ph.D thesis,
  93. (1998). Load history dependence of fatigue crack growth thresholds for a Ti-alloy’, doi
  94. (2002). Load-Interaction effects in simple mission spectra for Ti-17: Understanding the deformation before and after an underload’,
  95. (1967). Mechanics of crack tip deformation and extension by fatigue’, doi
  96. (1959). Metal Fatigue’,
  97. (1983). Micromechanisms of Fatigue crack growth retardation following overloads’, doi
  98. (2001). Modeling of Crack-Opening Stress Levels under Different Service Loading Spectra and Stress Levels for a 1045 Annealed Steel’, doi
  99. (1981). Multi-Parameter Yield Zone Model for Predicting Spectrum Crack Growth’, Methods and Models for Predicting Fatigue Crack Growth Under Random Loading, doi
  100. (1995). Near-Threshold fatigue crack growth in doi
  101. (1999). Near-Threshold fatigue: a review’, doi
  102. (1986). New Analytical Model for Prediction of Fatigue Crack Growth Under Realistic Loading’,
  103. (1967). Numerical Analysis Of Crack Propagation In A Cyclic Loaded Structure’, doi
  104. (2000). Numerical Modeling of Combined Roughness And Plasticity-Induced Crack Closure Effects In doi
  105. (1989). Observation Of Crack Closure Using A Crack Mouth Opening Displacement Gauge’, doi
  106. (1998). Overview of crack closure at near –threshold fatigue crack growth levels’, doi
  107. (1963). P a r i s , P . C . & E r d o g a n , F . , ‘ A c r i t ical analysis of crack propagation laws’,
  108. (1997). Physical Meaning Of ∆KRP And Fatigue Crack Propagation In The Residual Stress Distribution Field’, doi
  109. (1960). Plastic zone near a crack and fracture toughness’,
  110. Precise Determination Of Fatigue Crack Closure doi
  111. (2002). Predicting Fatigue Growth Using The KPR Concept’,
  112. (1998). Predicting the effects of load ratio on the fatigue crack rate and fatigue threshold’, doi
  113. (1980). Prediction Method For Fatigue Crack Growth In Aircraft Material’, doi
  114. (2002). Prediction of Crack Growth
  115. (2001). Prediction of Fatigue Crack Growth In Aluminium Alloys 2024-T351 Using Constraint Factors’, doi
  116. (1994). Prediction of fatigue crack growth under complex loading cycles’, doi
  117. Prediction of fatigue crack growth under variable amplitude and spectrum loading using a crack closure model’, doi
  118. (1999). Prediction of fatigue life under helicopter loading spectra for safe life and damage tolerance design’, doi
  119. (1976). Presentation of the Properties of a new High Strength Aluminium Alloy Designated 7010’, Aluminium Alloys in the Aircraft Industry,
  120. (1998). R i e m e l m o s e r , F . O . P i p p a n , doi
  121. (1981). Random Spectrum Fatigue Crack Life Predictions With or Without Considering Load Interactions’, Methods and Models for Predicting Fatigue Crack Growth Under Random Loading, doi
  122. (1999). Reflecting on the mechanical driving force of the fatigue crack propagation’, Fatigue and Fracture Mechanics: Twenty-Ninth Volume, doi
  123. Regulations, Part 29, Transport Category Helicopters, Section 29.571, Fatigue Evaluation of Structure, Federal Aviation Administration,
  124. Residual stress model for spectrum crack growth analysis’,
  125. (2000). Resistance curves for the threshold of fatigue crack propagation in particle reinforced Aluminium Alloys’, Fatigue Crack Growth Thresholds, Endurance Limits, and Design, doi
  126. (1997). Short crack growth and internal stresses’, doi
  127. (1997). Short Crack Growth Behavior’, Fatigue and Fracture doi
  128. (1973). Signal Processing Using Analog and Digital Techniques’, doi
  129. (1984). Standardised fatigue loading sequences for helicopter rotors (Helix and Felix), Part 2 Final definition of Helix and Felix’.
  130. Stress Intensity Factors Handbook, Vol1, Committee on Fracture Mechanics, T h e S o c i e t y o f M a t e r i a l S c i e n c e , J a p a n , Y . M u r a k a m i E d . P e r m a g o n P r e s s , doi
  131. (2000). Study Of Fatigue Crack Propagation And Extrinsic Toughening Of An Al-Li Alloy’, doi
  132. (2000). Systematic Assessment And Validation Of Compliance-Based Crack Closure Measurements In doi
  133. (1996). The ∆Keff concept: A unique and complete description of Fatigue Crack Propagation ’, doi
  134. (1994). The effect of overloads on threshold and crack closure’, doi
  135. The Influence Of Compressive Loads On Fatigue Crack Propagation In doi
  136. (1974). The influence of enviroment and stress ratio on fatigue crack growth at near threshold stress intensities in the low alloy steels’, doi
  137. (1999). The Influence Of Single And Multiple Overloads On Fatigue Crack Propagation’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  138. (2001). The material-dependent variability of fatigue crack growth rates of aluminium alloys in Paris regime’, doi
  139. (1981). The Mechanics of Fracture and Fatigue’, doi
  140. (1996). The Significance Of Crack Tip Deformation For Short And Long Fatigue Cracks’, Fatigue Fract. doi
  141. (1971). The significance of fatigue closure’, Damage Tolerance In doi
  142. (1994). The Significance Of RPG Load For Fatigue Crack Propagation And The Development Of A Compliance Measuring System’, doi
  143. (1973). The stress Analysis Of Cracks Handbook’, doi
  144. (1997). The three thresholds for fatigue crack propagation’, Fatigue nad Fracture Mechanics: 27 th Volume, doi
  145. Theoretical modelling of fatigue threshold for aluminium alloys’, doi
  146. (1993). Three Dimensional Elastic-Plastic Finite Element Analysis of Constrain Variations In doi
  147. (1992). Threshold Fatigue Crack Growth Prediction Under Spectrum Loading’, doi
  148. Ti-10V-2Fe-3Al Properties’, in R.R Boyer and H.W Rosenburg (Eds.) Beta Titanium Alloys in the 1980’s, Proceedingd of a symposium sponsored by the Titanium Committee of AIME, The Metallurgical Society, Atlants,
  149. (1993). Two critical stress intensities for threshold fatigue crack propagation’,
  150. (2002). WP810-Material Characterization and Enhanced Safe Life Data Collection’, Issue 1, GKN Westland Helicopters,
  151. (1960). Yielding Of Steel Sheets Containing Slits’, doi

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.