Skip to main content
Article thumbnail
Location of Repository

Workplace "Bargaining" and the Wages/Working Time Nexus - Who Benefits?

By Elsa Underhill, Santina Bertone and James Doughney


The impact of deregulation on dispersion of earnings in Victoria has been acknowledged in the findings of the recent task force enquiry into Industrial Relations in Victoria. This paper argues that the link between hours worked and rates of pay has played a significant, and understated, role in the increased dispersion of earnings evident in aggregate wages data. Drawing upon detailed analysis of hours and wages evident in Victorian agreements, data is presented on declining take-home pay flowing from hours worked coupled with loss of penalty rates. This, we argue, is attributable to the lack of substantive and procedural protections available to Victorian workers under Schedule 1A of the Workplace Relations Act, and formerly under the Victorian Employee Relations Act, 1992. We contrast these findings with collective agreements trading off penalty rates certified by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, and Australian Workplace Agreements approved by the Office of the Employment Advocate and the Commission. We conclude by suggesting there is a scale of fair outcomes attached to the wages/hours trade-off, directly attributable to the various institutional mechanisms now influencing Australian wage determination

Topics: School of Management and Information Systems, 350000 Commerce, Management, Tourism and Services, workplace, bargaining, wages, working time, benefits, industrial relations
Publisher: Victoria University
Year: 2002
OAI identifier:

Suggested articles


  1. (1996). A Study of the Changes to Wages and Conditions Under the Employee Relations Act
  2. (2000). Agreement making in Australia under the Workplace Relations Act,
  3. (1997). Australian Workplace Agreements - An Analysis,
  4. (2001). Australian Workplace Agreements in Practice: The 'Hard' and 'Soft' Dimensions,
  5. (2001). Average Weekly Earnings Time Series, Australia, Catalogue 6302.0, Austats.
  6. (2001). AWAs: Changing the Structure of Wages?,
  7. (1999). Bargained Out: Negotiating without unions in Australia, The Federation Press,
  8. (1998). Better or Worse Off? Analysis of a Range of Victorian Individual and Collective Employment Agreements,
  9. (1993). Efficiency and Equity at Work: The Need for Labour Market Regulation in Australia,
  10. (2000). Flexibility and Stretching Rights: The No Disadvantage Test in Enterprise Bargaining,
  11. Independent Report of the Victorian Industrial Relations Taskforce,
  12. (1965). Industrial Relations: What is Wrong with the System?,
  13. (1998). Informed Consent in Agreement Making Under the Workplace Relations Act
  14. (1997). New Approaches to the Vetting of Agreements, in New Rights and Remedies for Individual Employees - Implications for Employers and Unions, Australian Centre for Industrial Relations Research and Training, Working Paper 48.
  15. (1996). Protecting take-home pay: an the Coalition do better than Labour?,
  16. (1996). The Effects of Deregulation in the Victorian Labour Market: NonStandard Versus Full-Time Employees,
  17. (1994). The Industrial Relations Reform Act 1993: Counting the Cost,
  18. (2000). The Industrial Relations Taskforce Report: A Phoenix From The Ashes,
  19. (2001). The No Disadvantage Test: Failing Workers,
  20. (2000). Trends in processes in the making of Australian Workplace Agreements, Office of the Employment Advocate,
  21. (1994). Victoria's Employee Relations Act: The Way of the Future?,
  22. Voices from the Workplace, Independent Report of the Victorian Industrial Relations Taskforce, State of Victoria,
  23. (1995). Women and Enterprise Bargaining: The New Zealand Experience of Market Deregulation,
  24. (1999). Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (More Jobs, Better Pay) Bill 1999, A Personal Submission to the Senate Employment, Workplace Relations,

To submit an update or takedown request for this paper, please submit an Update/Correction/Removal Request.